Instituto Oswaldo Cruz, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil.
Escola de Medicina e Cirurgia, Universidade Federal do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil.
Cad Saude Publica. 2022 May 30;38(5):e00195421. doi: 10.1590/0102-311XPT195421. eCollection 2022.
Health crises spawn "sins" and moral deformities in society that are evident when they emerge but had seemed to be dormant to collective awareness before. Through the metaphor of the seven capital sins, the article analyzes the phenomenon of fake news in the social media and in the scenario of the COVID-19 pandemic: the lust of sensationalism through the seduction and exploitation of vulnerabilities associated with fear of death; gluttony for confirmatory contents that spread untruths in the attempt to turn versions into facts; the catechism of denialism, fueling wrath or hate in restrictive epistemic environments; the greed of new technologies in the attention economy through engagement as a new commodity; competition for the spotlights of media visibility and derived gains that incite pride and envy in researchers that confuse public meaning with fake research, in a cycle that feeds sensationalism, gluttony, hate, and greed in attention capitalism. Finally, sloth is portrayed as the capital sin of opting for communicative inaction. In the comfort of bubbles, people renounce dialogue out of aversion to dissent, settling for positions of epistemic comfort. In short, the fake news phenomenon in the COVID-19 pandemic is portrayed here as the convergence of various vices that materialize as misinformation, in the communicative vacuity of the moments in which we are obliged to address each other to share our worldviews.
健康危机在社会中滋生“罪恶”和道德畸形,这些罪恶和畸形在出现时显而易见,但在之前似乎已经潜伏在集体意识中。本文通过七宗罪的隐喻,分析了社交媒体和 COVID-19 大流行背景下假新闻的现象:通过对与对死亡的恐惧相关的弱点的诱惑和利用,产生了轰动效应的欲望;暴食证实性内容,传播虚假信息,试图将版本变成事实;否认主义的教义,在限制认知环境中煽动愤怒或仇恨;在注意力经济中对新技术的贪婪,通过参与作为一种新的商品;争夺媒体能见度的焦点和衍生收益,激发研究人员的骄傲和嫉妒,他们将公共意义与虚假研究混淆,这种循环助长了轰动效应、暴食、仇恨和贪婪在关注资本主义中的作用。最后,懒惰被描绘为选择沟通不作为的罪恶。人们在泡沫的舒适中,出于对异议的厌恶而放弃对话,选择了知识上的舒适立场。简而言之,本文将 COVID-19 大流行中的假新闻现象描绘为各种罪恶的汇聚,这些罪恶以错误信息的形式表现出来,反映了我们在必须相互交流以分享世界观的时刻中存在的沟通空洞。