Department of Psychology, Colorado State University.
Independent Practice.
Dev Psychol. 2022 Oct;58(10):1887-1911. doi: 10.1037/dev0001404. Epub 2022 Jun 2.
Theory and research have described developmental processes leading to damaged parent-child relationships, such as those that occur during a divorce. However, scholars dispute the scientific status of the literature on children who form unhealthy alliances with one parent against the other-termed parental alienation (PA). This comprehensive literature review tests competing descriptions of the PA literature. Accessing four electronic databases, we identified 213 documents with empirical data on PA published in 10 languages through December 2020. The results confirmed that the current state of PA scholarship meets three criteria of a maturing field of scientific inquiry: an expanding literature, a shift toward quantitative studies, and a growing body of research that tests theory-generated hypotheses. Nearly 40% of the PA literature has been published since 2016, establishing that PA research has moved beyond an early stage of scientific development and has produced a scientifically trustworthy knowledge base. This literature review documents the value of multiple research methodologies to this knowledge base. In addition, the growing body of research described in this review enhances our understanding of the association between interparental conflict and the breakdown of parent-child relationships in families where conflict differentially affects children's relationship with and behavior toward each parent. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
理论和研究描述了导致亲子关系受损的发展过程,例如在离婚期间发生的情况。然而,学者们对有关儿童与父母一方形成不健康联盟的文献的科学地位存在争议,这些文献被称为父母离异(PA)。本综述文献检验了 PA 文献的竞争性描述。通过访问四个电子数据库,我们确定了截至 2020 年 12 月,以 10 种语言发表的关于 PA 的具有实证数据的 213 篇文献。结果证实,PA 奖学金的现状符合科学探究成熟领域的三个标准:文献不断扩展、向定量研究转变,以及越来越多的研究检验了基于理论的假设。近 40%的 PA 文献是在 2016 年之后发表的,这表明 PA 研究已经超越了科学发展的早期阶段,并产生了具有科学可信度的知识库。本文献综述记录了多种研究方法对这一知识库的价值。此外,本综述中描述的越来越多的研究增强了我们对父母间冲突与家庭中亲子关系破裂之间关联的理解,在这些家庭中,冲突对孩子与父母双方的关系和行为产生了不同的影响。(PsycInfo 数据库记录(c)2022 APA,保留所有权利)。