Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University Hospital of Modena, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy.
Department of Thoracic Surgery, Ospedale Maggiore della Carità di Novara, Novara, Italy.
Updates Surg. 2022 Jun;74(3):803-816. doi: 10.1007/s13304-022-01304-7. Epub 2022 Jun 3.
Many studies documented the "glass ceiling" effect for women in surgery: achievements in academic and leadership positions are not consistent with the percentage of female surgeons in practice. A solid surgical case volume and expertise in high-complexity cases are required to pursue leadership positions. The aim of the study was to determine whether part of the difficulties encountered by female surgeons may lie in reduced surgical opportunities. This is the first study to investigate this issue in Italy. An online survey, conceived and promoted by Women in Surgery Italia, was administered through the RedCap platform, between November and December 2020, and female surgeons actively working in Italian academic and non-academic hospitals were invited to answer anonymously. A multivariate analysis was performed to evaluate the role of different factors on two main variables: overall procedures done and a sub-analysis of complex cases performed as first surgeon. 1810 respondents were included; the women who responded participated in 3% fewer cases on average, when compared to the mean staff case volume, and were significantly more often listed as the assistant surgeon and as primary surgeons in low-complexity cases. 36.5% of the respondents declared that at least one female physician on staff had to abandon the operatory room (OR) and does not regularly perform any surgical procedure. 73% female surgeons would like to spend more hours in the OR. While acquiring skills and surgical autonomy, many obstacles still exist for female surgeons. A portion of women are relegated to non-surgical activities, irrespective of their specialty, and these results confirm the theory that gender-biased underemployment still exists in surgical fields.
许多研究都记录了女性在外科领域中面临的“玻璃天花板”效应:在学术和领导职位上的成就与实践中女性外科医生的比例不一致。要追求领导职位,需要有坚实的外科手术量和处理高复杂性病例的专业知识。本研究旨在确定女性外科医生所面临的部分困难是否可能源于手术机会减少。这是意大利首次对此问题进行的研究。一项在线调查由 Women in Surgery Italia 构思和推广,通过 RedCap 平台在 2020 年 11 月至 12 月期间进行,邀请在意大利学术和非学术医院积极工作的女性外科医生匿名回答。进行了多变量分析,以评估两个主要变量(总手术量和作为第一外科医生进行的复杂病例的亚分析)中不同因素的作用。共纳入 1810 名受访者;与平均员工病例量相比,回答问题的女性平均参与的手术少 3%,并且她们作为助手外科医生和低复杂性病例的主要外科医生的比例明显更高。36.5%的受访者表示,至少有一名在职女医生不得不放弃手术室(OR),并且不再定期进行任何手术。73%的女性外科医生希望在 OR 中花费更多时间。虽然女性外科医生在获得技能和手术自主权方面取得了进展,但仍存在许多障碍。一部分女性被降级从事非手术活动,而不论其专业如何,这些结果证实了性别偏见性就业不足仍存在于外科领域的理论。