Saleh Shadi, Mansour Rania, Daou Tracy, Brome Dayana, Naal Hady
Global Health Institute, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Faculty of Health Sciences, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Confl Health. 2022 Jun 3;16(1):31. doi: 10.1186/s13031-022-00462-0.
Given the magnitude and frequency of conflicts in the MENA region along with their devastating impact on health responses and outcomes, there exists a strong need to invest in contextualized, innovative, and accessible capacity building approaches to enhance leadership and skills in global health. The MENA region suffers from limited (1) continued educational and career progression opportunities, (2) gender balance, and (3) skill-mix among its health workforce, which require significant attention.
The Global Health Institute at the American University of Beirut incepted the Academy division to develop and implement various global health capacity building (GHCB) initiatives to address those challenges in fragile settings across low-and middle-income countries in the MENA region. These initiatives play a strategic role in this context, especially given their focus on being accessible through employing innovative learning modalities. However, there exists a dearth of evidence-based knowledge on best practices and recommendations to optimize the design, implementation, and evaluation of GHCB in fragile settings in the MENA region. The present paper describes the development of the evaluation of capacity building program (eCAP), implemented under the Academy division, to assess the effectiveness of its initiatives. eCAP is composed of 3 phases: (1) a situational assessment, followed by (2) production of multiple case studies, and finally (3) a meta-assessment leading to model development. The goal of eCAP is not only to inform the Academy's operations, but also to synthesize produced knowledge into the formation of an evidence-based, scalable, and replicable model for GHCB in fragile settings.
eCAP is an important initiative for researchers, educators, and practitioners interested in GHCB in fragile settings. Several lessons can be learned from the outcomes it has yielded so far in its first two phases of implementation, ranging from the situational assessment to the production of evaluation case studies, which are expanded on in the manuscript along with pertinent challenges.
鉴于中东和北非地区冲突的规模和频率及其对卫生应对措施和成果的破坏性影响,迫切需要投资于因地制宜、创新且易于获取的能力建设方法,以提升全球卫生领域的领导力和技能。中东中东中东和北非地区在以下几个方面存在不足:(1)持续教育和职业发展机会有限;(2)性别平衡问题;(3)卫生人力技能组合不合理,这些都需要引起高度关注。
贝鲁特美国大学全球卫生研究所设立了学院部门,以制定和实施各种全球卫生能力建设(GHCB)举措,应对中东和北非地区低收入和中等收入国家脆弱环境中的这些挑战。在这种背景下,这些举措发挥着战略作用,特别是考虑到它们通过采用创新学习模式来实现易于获取的目标。然而,在中东和北非地区脆弱环境中,关于优化全球卫生能力建设的设计、实施和评估的最佳实践和建议,缺乏基于证据的知识。本文描述了在学院部门实施的能力建设项目评估(eCAP)的开展情况,以评估其举措的有效性。eCAP由三个阶段组成:(1)形势评估,接着是(2)多个案例研究的产出,最后是(3)导致模型开发的元评估。eCAP的目标不仅是为学院的运作提供信息,还将所产生的知识综合形成一个基于证据、可扩展且可复制的脆弱环境中全球卫生能力建设模型。
eCAP对于关注脆弱环境中全球卫生能力建设的研究人员、教育工作者和从业者来说是一项重要举措。从其实施的前两个阶段(从形势评估到评估案例研究的产出)所产生的结果中可以吸取一些经验教训,本文将详细阐述这些经验教训以及相关挑战。