Department of Pediatrics, Wayne State University, USA.
Department of Epileptology, Tohoku University Graduate School of Medicine, Japan.
Intern Med. 2022 Aug 15;61(16):2431-2440. doi: 10.2169/internalmedicine.9291-21. Epub 2022 Jun 7.
Objective This cross-sectional national study determined which educational approaches are associated with the effectiveness of online clerkship for medical students. Method A survey was conducted for medical students at 78 medical schools in Japan from May 29 to June 14, 2020. It comprised the following aspects: (a) participants' profiles, (b) number of opportunities to learn from each educational approach (lecture, medical quiz, assignment, oral presentation, observation of a physician's practice, clinical skill practice, participation in interprofessional meetings, and interactive discussions with physicians) in online clerkship, (c) frequency of technical problems, and (d) educational outcome measurement (satisfaction, motivation, knowledge acquisition, skill acquisition, change in self-study time, and understanding of the importance of medical care team). Results Of the 2,640 respondents, 2,594 (98.3%) agreed to cooperate. Ultimately, 1,711 matched our inclusion criteria. All educational approaches but assignments were positively associated with satisfaction and motivation. All educational approaches excluding assignment submission and interprofessional meeting were positively associated with knowledge acquisition. Observation, practice, and interprofessional meeting were positively associated with skill acquisition. Only assignment submission was positively associated with the change in self-study time. Educational approaches excluding medical quizzes were positively associated with understanding the importance of the medical care team. Technical problems were negatively associated with motivation, knowledge acquisition, and skill acquisition. Conclusions Educators should implement various educational approaches, especially observation and practice, even in online clinical clerkship. They also need to minimize the technical problems associated with the Internet, as they reduce the effectiveness of online clerkship.
目的 本横断面全国性研究旨在确定哪些教育方法与医学生在线实习的效果相关。
方法 2020 年 5 月 29 日至 6 月 14 日,对日本 78 所医学院的医学生进行了一项调查。它包括以下方面:(a)参与者的个人资料,(b)从每种教育方法(讲座、医学测验、作业、口头报告、观察医生的实践、临床技能练习、参与跨专业会议和与医生的互动讨论)在线实习中学习的机会数量,(c)技术问题的频率,以及(d)教育成果测量(满意度、动机、知识获取、技能获取、自学时间的变化以及对医疗保健团队重要性的理解)。
结果 在 2640 名受访者中,有 2594 名(98.3%)同意合作。最终,有 1711 名符合我们的纳入标准。除作业外,所有教育方法均与满意度和动机呈正相关。除作业提交和跨专业会议外,所有教育方法均与知识获取呈正相关。观察、实践和跨专业会议与技能获取呈正相关。只有作业提交与自学时间的变化呈正相关。除医学测验外,所有教育方法均与对医疗保健团队重要性的理解呈正相关。技术问题与动机、知识获取和技能获取呈负相关。
结论 教育者应实施各种教育方法,尤其是观察和实践,即使是在在线临床实习中。他们还需要尽量减少与互联网相关的技术问题,因为这些问题会降低在线实习的效果。