Department of Psychology, Clemson University, 321 Calhoun Dr., Clemson, SC, 29634, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL, USA.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2022 Aug;84(6):2060-2073. doi: 10.3758/s13414-022-02504-4. Epub 2022 Jun 8.
The present studies investigated how three core aspects of executive functioning may be influenced by the presence of depth information. Specifically, participants were assigned to one of three executive functioning tasks: working memory (i.e., a change detection task), selective attention (i.e., a visual search task), or inhibitory control (i.e., a flanker task). For all three tasks, participants completed trials where the items in the display were presented either all in one depth plane or the target item was isolated in depth. For the working memory and selective attention tasks, there was an additional condition where items were evenly distributed across two depth planes. Each task also had multiple levels of difficulty to explore if task conditions influence the effect of depth information. Results indicated that although depth information can improve both working memory and selective attention performance, this benefit is specific to the task difficulty and depth information can even hinder performance under certain circumstances. Depth information did not appear to influence inhibitory control performance. Future work is required to investigate if depth can improve inhibitory control performance, and how/what task conditions influence the benefit of depth information. Until further research is completed, researchers and designers should be cautious when implementing multidimensional (3D) displays, as it remains unclear if the performance benefits of including depth information outweigh the present costs.
本研究旨在探讨执行功能的三个核心方面如何受到深度信息的影响。具体来说,参与者被分配到三种执行功能任务之一:工作记忆(即变化检测任务)、选择性注意(即视觉搜索任务)或抑制控制(即侧抑制任务)。对于所有三个任务,参与者都完成了显示中的项目要么全部在一个深度平面上呈现,要么目标项目在深度上孤立的试验。对于工作记忆和选择性注意任务,还有一个额外的条件,其中项目均匀分布在两个深度平面上。每个任务也有多个难度级别,以探索任务条件是否会影响深度信息的影响。结果表明,尽管深度信息可以提高工作记忆和选择性注意的表现,但这种益处是特定于任务难度的,并且在某些情况下,深度信息甚至会阻碍表现。深度信息似乎不会影响抑制控制的表现。需要进一步的研究来探讨深度是否可以提高抑制控制的表现,以及任务条件如何/什么影响深度信息的益处。在进一步的研究完成之前,研究人员和设计师在实施多维(3D)显示时应谨慎,因为目前尚不清楚包含深度信息的性能优势是否超过了当前的成本。