Raman S, Dulberg C S, Spasoff R A, Scott T
CMAJ. 1987 May 15;136(10):1051-6.
We carried out a cohort study of mortality among 954 Canadian military personnel exposed to low-dose ionizing radiation during nuclear reactor clean-up operations at Chalk River Nuclear Laboratories, Chalk River, Ont., and during observation of atomic test blasts in the United States and Australia in the 1950s. Two controls matched for age, service, rank and trade were selected for each exposed subject. Mortality among the exposed and control groups was ascertained by means of record linkage with the Canadian Mortality Data Base. Survival analysis with life-table techniques did not reveal any difference in overall mortality between the exposed and control groups. Analysis of cause-specific mortality showed similar mortality patterns in the two groups; there was no elevation in the exposed group in the frequency of death from leukemia or thyroid cancer, the causes of death most often associated with radiation exposure. Analysis of survival by recorded gamma radiation dose also did not show any effect of radiation dose on mortality. The findings are in agreement with the current scientific literature on the risk of death from exposure to low-dose radiation.
我们对954名加拿大军事人员进行了一项队列研究,这些人员在安大略省乔克河的乔克河核实验室进行核反应堆清理作业期间,以及在20世纪50年代美国和澳大利亚的原子弹试验爆炸观测期间,暴露于低剂量电离辐射。为每名暴露对象选取两名在年龄、服役情况、军衔和工种方面匹配的对照。通过与加拿大死亡率数据库进行记录链接,确定暴露组和对照组的死亡率。采用生命表技术进行的生存分析未发现暴露组和对照组在总体死亡率上存在任何差异。对特定病因死亡率的分析显示,两组的死亡率模式相似;暴露组中白血病或甲状腺癌(最常与辐射暴露相关的死因)的死亡频率没有升高。按记录的γ辐射剂量进行的生存分析也未显示辐射剂量对死亡率有任何影响。这些发现与当前关于低剂量辐射暴露死亡风险的科学文献一致。