Ng Tony Kwun-Tung, Lin Jui-An, Sasaki Sumire
Pain Management Unit, Department of Anaesthesia and Operating Theatre Services, Tuen Mun Hospital, 23 Tsing Chung Koon Road, Tuen Mun, Hong Kong, China.
Department of Anaesthesiology, LKS Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong, China.
Healthcare (Basel). 2022 May 28;10(6):1002. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10061002.
Introduction: With an increasingly ageing population, there is a growing impact of fragility hip fracture on the healthcare system and on society as a whole. Oral and injectable analgesics are often insufficient whilst traction and regional blocks do not allow patients to be discharged easily. While the conventional approach of ultrasound-guided anterior hip pericapsular neurolysis can help a lot of inoperable hip fracture patients to relieve their fracture pain and facilitate subsequent nursing care, enormous technical challenges are encountered in some cases. In this retrospective case study, we evaluated the overall pain and functional outcomes of our modified approach of anterior hip pericapsular neurolysis for inoperable hip fractures using the IDEAL framework. Method: This retrospective case series studied patients with acute inoperable hip fracture who received the modified approach of anterior hip pericapsular neurolysis from January 2018 to June 2019 according to the IDEAL recommendations. The modified approach consisted of pericapsular nerve group (PENG) injection, iliopsoas plane infiltration, and the sagittal approach of obturator nerve articular branches (ONAB) injection. Subsequent alcohol neurolysis would be performed in the same setting if there were positive diagnostic blocks. Assessments were carried out on post-intervention day 5. The primary outcome was pain intensity during hip flexion at 80 degrees in the recumbent position and during gentle hip internal and external rotation using an appropriate pain scoring tool. The secondary outcomes were the range of tolerable hip flexion and occurrence of any lower limb neurological deficit because of the procedure. Interim outcomes were also briefly evaluated. Results: Among the 74 patients who were reviewed in the study period, the median dynamic pain at hip flexion 80° (p < 0.001) and on gentle hip external and internal rotation (p < 0.001) was significantly reduced from a composite score of 3 (severe pain) to 1 (mild pain) on post-intervention day 5 after the modified approach of hip neurolysis. This translated to 72% of patients achieving satisfactory pain control, which was defined as a composite pain score of ≤1 on hip flexion at 80°. Functionally, the mean range of tolerable hip flexion significantly improved from 39.7° at baseline to 74° on post-intervention day 5 (p < 0.001). Transient and reversible hypotension was seen in about 10% of the patients. No other major procedural adverse event was noted. Interim follow-up at 4−6 months post-intervention revealed that more than 95% of patients continued to have satisfactory dynamic pain control (i.e., composite pain score ≤ 1). According to the IDEAL classification, this study could be ranked as stage 2a (development). Conclusions: Our findings suggested that anterior hip pericapsular neurolysis using a modified approach could offer consistent and satisfactory analgesic and functional benefits to a majority of patients with inoperable hip fractures during the interim of the fracture healing process, and it was potentially safer than the conventional approach. This technique might have achieved its readiness to proceed to the next stage of research according to the IDEAL framework.
随着人口老龄化日益加剧,髋部脆性骨折对医疗系统乃至整个社会的影响越来越大。口服和注射用镇痛药往往效果不佳,而牵引和区域阻滞又不利于患者轻松出院。虽然传统的超声引导下髋关节前关节囊周围神经松解术能帮助许多无法手术的髋部骨折患者缓解骨折疼痛并便于后续护理,但在某些情况下会遇到巨大的技术挑战。在这项回顾性病例研究中,我们使用IDEAL框架评估了改良的髋关节前关节囊周围神经松解术治疗无法手术的髋部骨折的总体疼痛和功能结果。
本回顾性病例系列研究了2018年1月至2019年6月期间根据IDEAL建议接受改良髋关节前关节囊周围神经松解术的急性无法手术的髋部骨折患者。改良方法包括关节囊周围神经组(PENG)注射、髂腰肌平面浸润以及闭孔神经关节支(ONAB)注射的矢状入路。如果诊断性阻滞呈阳性,则在相同情况下进行后续酒精神经松解术。在干预后第5天进行评估。主要结局是使用适当的疼痛评分工具评估仰卧位时髋关节屈曲80度以及髋关节轻柔内旋和外旋时的疼痛强度。次要结局是可耐受的髋关节屈曲范围以及因该手术导致的任何下肢神经功能缺损的发生情况。还简要评估了中期结局。
在研究期间接受评估的74例患者中,改良髋关节神经松解术后第5天,髋关节屈曲80°(p < 0.001)以及髋关节轻柔外旋和内旋时(p < 0.001)的中位动态疼痛从综合评分3分(重度疼痛)显著降至1分(轻度疼痛)。这意味着72%的患者实现了满意的疼痛控制,满意的疼痛控制定义为髋关节屈曲80°时综合疼痛评分≤1分。在功能方面,可耐受的髋关节屈曲平均范围从基线时 的39.7°显著改善至干预后第5天的74°(p < 0.001)。约10%的患者出现短暂且可逆的低血压。未观察到其他重大手术不良事件。干预后4 - 6个月的中期随访显示,超过95%的患者持续保持满意的动态疼痛控制(即综合疼痛评分≤1)。根据IDEAL分类,本研究可列为2a期(发展期)。
我们 的研究结果表明改良的髋关节前关节囊周围神经松解术在骨折愈合过程的中期可为大多数无法手术的髋部骨折患者提供持续且满意的镇痛和功能益处,并且可能比传统方法更安全。根据IDEAL框架,这项技术可能已准备好进入下一阶段的研究。