Bisht Shrestha, Khera Amit Kumar, Raghav Pradeep
Department of Orthodontics, Subharti Dental College, Swamivivekanand Subharti University, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, India.
J Orthod Sci. 2022 May 4;11:9. doi: 10.4103/jos.jos_170_21. eCollection 2022.
White spot lesions (WSL) are an unsightly and a rather frequent drawback of orthodontic treatment. The complex design of fixed orthodontic appliances (FAs) makes it difficult to perform proper oral hygiene, which amounts to white spot lesions being three times more prevalent in patients wearing orthodontic appliances. As clear thermoplastic aligners (CAs) are removable appliances, it has been speculated that they allow better oral hygiene maintenance and thus less incidence of WSLs.
This evidence-based scoping review aims to identify the scope and nature of the evidence on white spot lesions during orthodontic clear aligner therapy.
Strategic and thorough search of the literature for randomized Controlled Trials, Case-Control, Cohort studies, Case reports, full research articles, and review papers on humans published in English in five major databases was undertaken till July 2021 using free text and Medical Subject Headings (MESH) terms, followed by Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) to identify five studies for data extraction.
Evidence was summarized for study characteristics, diagnostic methods for the detection of white spot lesions, and incidence of white spot lesions during clear aligner therapy. The literature supports that orthodontic treatment with CAs was associated with a low incidence of WSLs when compared with fixed mechanotherapy, with a major role of patient education, motivation, and compliance in maintaining oral hygiene.
The general perception is that clear aligners are more hygienic and show no incidence of white spot lesions. However, our scoping review supports that WSLs can occur with this form of orthodontic treatment also. WSLs in clear aligners could be attributed to the practice of having composite attachments that cover a significant portion of the tooth surface. Thus, regardless of the type of appliance used, a periodic reinforcement by the orthodontist to maintain oral hygiene is necessary for patient motivation, allowing for better oral hygiene practice, and as a result, leads to prevention of WSLs.
白斑病变(WSL)是正畸治疗中一个难看且相当常见的问题。固定正畸矫治器(FA)的复杂设计使得保持良好的口腔卫生变得困难,这导致佩戴正畸矫治器的患者中白斑病变的发生率高出三倍。由于透明热塑性矫治器(CA)是可摘矫治器,据推测它们能让患者更好地保持口腔卫生,从而降低白斑病变的发生率。
本循证范围综述旨在确定正畸透明矫治器治疗期间白斑病变相关证据的范围和性质。
截至2021年7月,在五个主要数据库中对以英文发表的关于人类的随机对照试验、病例对照研究、队列研究、病例报告、完整研究文章和综述论文进行了全面且系统的文献检索,使用了自由文本和医学主题词(MESH),随后按照系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)来确定五项研究进行数据提取。
总结了关于研究特征、白斑病变检测的诊断方法以及透明矫治器治疗期间白斑病变发生率的证据。文献支持,与固定机械治疗相比,使用CA进行正畸治疗时白斑病变的发生率较低,患者教育、积极性和依从性在保持口腔卫生方面起主要作用。
一般认为透明矫治器更卫生且不会出现白斑病变。然而,我们的范围综述支持这种正畸治疗形式也可能出现白斑病变。透明矫治器中的白斑病变可能归因于复合附件覆盖了很大一部分牙面的情况。因此,无论使用何种矫治器类型,正畸医生定期加强指导以保持口腔卫生对于激发患者积极性、促使患者更好地保持口腔卫生并预防白斑病变都是必要的。