Holland Katherine, Haegele Justin A, Zhu Xihe, Bobzien Jonna
Department of Teacher Education, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
Department of Human Movement Sciences, Old Dominion University, Norfolk, Virginia USA.
J Dev Phys Disabil. 2023;35(2):273-293. doi: 10.1007/s10882-022-09852-x. Epub 2022 Jun 22.
This study examined how students with orthopedic impairments experienced strategies identified in the literature to support 'inclusion'. An interpretative phenomenological analysis research approach was used, and six students with orthopedic impairments (age 10-14 years) served as participants. Data sources were written prompts, semi-structured, audiotaped interviews, and reflective interview notes. Based on thematic data analysis, four themes were constructed: "It's kind of embarrassing": experiences with support; "I don't want to be different": equipment, activity, and rule modifications; "I like to be a part of the conversation": autonomy and choice in PE; and "I would rather be like the other students": discussing disability. The experiences portrayed through these themes highlighted the differential effects of these explicated strategies, where each strategy contributed to feelings of inclusion, as well as marginalization among participants. As such, the findings indicated that 'inclusive' strategies should not be considered as blanket recommendations; instead, attempts to promote 'inclusion' of students with disabilities should start with a reflexive look at the unique needs of each individual student.
本研究考察了有肢体残疾的学生如何体验文献中所确定的支持“融合”的策略。采用了解释现象学分析研究方法,六名有肢体残疾的学生(年龄在10至14岁之间)作为参与者。数据来源包括书面提示、半结构化录音访谈以及反思性访谈笔记。基于主题数据分析,构建了四个主题:“这有点尴尬”:支持体验;“我不想与众不同”:设备、活动和规则调整;“我想参与对话”:体育课程中的自主性和选择权;以及“我宁愿和其他学生一样”:讨论残疾问题。通过这些主题所描绘的经历突出了这些明确策略的不同效果,其中每种策略都对融合感以及参与者中的边缘化产生了影响。因此,研究结果表明,“融合”策略不应被视为一概而论的建议;相反,促进残疾学生“融合”的尝试应从反思每个学生的独特需求开始。