Rizzo M I, Fallico N, Beneduce N, Ruoppolo G, Ciofalo A, Vagnoni S, Palmieri A, De Virgilio A, Greco A, Zama M
Ospedale Pediatrico Bambino Gesù, Department of Plastic and Maxillo-facial surgery, Piazza di Sant'Onofrio 4, 00165 Roma, Italy.
Spires Cleft Centre, Salisbury Oxford, UK.
J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022 Sep;75(9):3448-3456. doi: 10.1016/j.bjps.2022.02.024. Epub 2022 Feb 25.
Velopharyngeal dysfunction (VPD) diagnosis and speech surgery outcomes are currently based solely on subjective evaluation criteria consisting of perceptual speech assessment and functional imaging. This study describes an objective and comparable method in VPD assessment and investigates the concurrence between the objective and subjective evaluations. The present study included 20 paediatric patients presenting with VPD after primary repair (intravelar veloplasty) of cleft palate. Our protocol was based on computerized analysis of voice parameters by means of an objective tool, spectrography integrated with Multi-Dimensional Voice Program (MDVP). The protocol also included perceptual evaluation by speech therapist and phoniatrician (consensus listening), and parents. This is a single surgeon, single centre experience and all patients underwent a secondary Furlow's palatoplasty. Assessments were performed pre- and postoperatively and upon completion of speech therapy. Results were compared using the two-tailed t student test for paired data. Statistical significance was set for p-values <0.05. Data analysis confirmed an improvement in velopharyngeal closure after surgery and speech therapy consistently with the results of perceptual evaluations. The results of the study confirmed the availability and reliability of an objective method for VPD evaluation based on the analysis of voice parameters with investigations that are simple and easily available in a hospital setting.
腭咽功能障碍(VPD)的诊断和言语手术结果目前完全基于主观评估标准,包括言语感知评估和功能成像。本研究描述了一种用于VPD评估的客观且具有可比性的方法,并调查了客观评估与主观评估之间的一致性。本研究纳入了20例腭裂一期修复(腭内肌成形术)后出现VPD的儿科患者。我们的方案基于使用一种客观工具——与多维语音程序(MDVP)集成的频谱分析对语音参数进行计算机分析。该方案还包括言语治疗师和耳鼻喉科医生(共识性听力评估)以及家长的感知评估。这是一项单外科医生、单中心的经验研究,所有患者均接受了二次Furlow腭成形术。在术前、术后以及言语治疗完成后进行评估。使用配对数据的双尾t检验对结果进行比较。设定p值<0.05为具有统计学意义。数据分析证实,手术和言语治疗后腭咽闭合情况有所改善,与感知评估结果一致。研究结果证实了一种基于语音参数分析的VPD评估客观方法的可用性和可靠性,该方法所涉及的检查在医院环境中简单且易于实施。