Li-Sauerwine Simiao, Bambach Kimberly, McGrath Jillian, Yee Jennifer, Boulger Creagh T, Hunold Katherine M, Mitzman Jennifer
Department of Emergency Medicine The Ohio State University Columbus Ohio USA.
Nationwide Children's Hospital Columbus Ohio USA.
AEM Educ Train. 2022 Jun 23;6(3):e10763. doi: 10.1002/aet2.10763. eCollection 2022 Jun.
Women comprise 28% of faculty in academic departments of emergency medicine (EM) and 11% of academic chairs. Professional development programs for women are key to career success and to prevent pipeline attrition. Within emergency medicine, there is a paucity of outcomes-level data for such programs.
We aim to measure the impact of a novel structured professional development curriculum and mentorship group (Resident and Faculty Female Tribe, or RAFFT) within an academic department of EM.
This prospective single-center curriculum implementation and evaluation was conducted in the academic year 2020-2021. A planning group identified potential curricular topics using an iterative Delphi process. We developed a 10-session longitudinal curriculum; a postcurriculum survey was conducted to assess the perceived benefit of the program in four domains.
A total of 76% of 51 eligible women attended at least one session; for this project we analyzed the 24 participants (47%) who attended at least one session and completed both the pre- and the postsurvey. The majority of participants reported a positive benefit, which aligned with their expectations in the following areas: professional development (79.2%), job satisfaction (83.3%), professional well-being (70.8%), and personal well-being (79.2%). Resident physicians more often reported less benefit than expected compared to fellow/faculty physicians. Median perceived impact on career choice and trajectory was positive for all respondents.
Success of this professional development program was measured through a perceived benefit aligning with participant expectations, a positive impact on career choice and career trajectory for participants in each career stage, and a high level of engagement in this voluntary program. Recommendations for the successful implementation of professional development programs include early engagement of stakeholders, the application of data from a program-specific needs assessment, early dissemination of session dates to allow for protected time off, and structured discussions with appropriate identification of presession resources.
在急诊医学学术部门中,女性占教员的28%,担任学术主席的占11%。针对女性的职业发展项目是职业成功和防止人才流失的关键。在急诊医学领域,此类项目缺乏成果层面的数据。
我们旨在评估急诊医学学术部门内一个新颖的结构化职业发展课程和导师小组(住院医师与教员女性部落,简称RAFFT)的影响。
这项前瞻性单中心课程实施与评估于2020 - 2021学年进行。一个规划小组通过迭代德尔菲法确定潜在的课程主题。我们制定了一个为期10节的纵向课程;课程结束后进行了一项调查,以评估该项目在四个领域的感知效益。
51名符合条件的女性中,共有76%至少参加了一次课程;在本项目中,我们分析了至少参加过一次课程并完成了课前和课后调查的24名参与者(占47%)。大多数参与者报告了积极的效益,这与她们在以下方面的期望相符:职业发展(79.2%)、工作满意度(83.3%)、职业幸福感(70.8%)和个人幸福感(79.2%)。与住院医师相比,住院医师更常报告效益低于预期。所有受访者对职业选择和轨迹的感知影响中位数为积极。
该职业发展项目的成功通过与参与者期望相符的感知效益、对每个职业阶段参与者的职业选择和职业轨迹产生的积极影响以及该自愿项目的高参与度来衡量。成功实施职业发展项目的建议包括利益相关者的早期参与、应用来自特定项目需求评估的数据、提前公布课程日期以便安排专门的休息时间,以及进行结构化讨论并适当确定课前资源。