Clinical Research Unit, Aga Khan University Hospital, Nairobi, Kenya.
Department of Haematology and Oncology, Aga Khan University Hospital, Nairobi, Kenya.
PLoS One. 2022 Jul 1;17(7):e0270594. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0270594. eCollection 2022.
Low dose radiation therapy (LDRT) has been used for non-malignant conditions since early 1900s based on the ability of single fractions between 50-150 cGy to inhibit cellular proliferation. Given scarcity of resources, poor access to vaccines and medical therapies within low and middle income countries, there is an urgent need to identify other cost-effective alternatives in management of COVID-19 pneumonia. We conducted a pilot phase Ib/II investigator-initiated clinical trial to assess the safety, feasibility, and toxicity of LDRT in patients with severe COVID-19 pneumonia at the Aga Khan University Hospital in Nairobi, Kenya. Additionally, we also assessed clinical benefit in terms of improvement in oxygenation at day 3 following LDRT and the ability to avoid mechanical ventilation at day 7 post LDRT.
Patients with both polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and high-resolution computer tomogram (HRCT) confirmed severe COVID-19 pneumonia, not improving on conventional therapy including Dexamethasone and with increasing oxygen requirement were enrolled in the study. Patients on mechanical ventilation were excluded. Eligible patients received a single 100cGy fraction to the whole lung. In the absence of any dose limiting toxicity the study proposed to treat a total of 10 patients. The primary endpoints were to assess the safety/feasibility, and toxicity within the first 24 hours post LDRT. The secondary endpoints were to assess efficacy of LDRT at Day 3, 7, 14 and 28 post LDRT.
Ten patients were treated with LDRT. All (100%) of patients were able to complete LDRT without treatment related SAE within the first 24 hours post treatment. None of the patients treated with LDRT experienced any acute toxicity as defined by change in clinical and respiratory status at 24hr following LDRT. Majority (90%) of patients avoided mechanical ventilation within 7 days of LDRT. Four patients (40%) demonstrated at least 25% improvement in oxygen requirements within 3 days. Six patients (60%) were discharged and remained off oxygen, whereas four progressed and died (1 due to sepsis and 3 in cytokine storm). Median time to discharge (n = 6) was 16.5 days and median time to death (n = 4) was 11.0 days. Patients who ultimately died showed elevated inflammatory markers including Ferritin, CRP and D-dimers as compared to those who were discharged alive.
LDRT was feasible, safe and shows promise in the management of severe COVID-19 pneumonia including in patients progressing on conventional systemic treatment. Additional phase II trials are warranted to identify patients most likely to benefit from LDRT.
自 20 世纪初以来,低剂量辐射疗法(LDRT)已被用于治疗非恶性疾病,其依据是单次剂量在 50-150cGy 之间能够抑制细胞增殖。鉴于资源匮乏、中低收入国家疫苗和医疗疗法获取不足,因此迫切需要在管理 COVID-19 肺炎方面寻找其他具有成本效益的替代方法。我们在内罗毕的 Aga Khan 大学医院进行了一项由研究者发起的 Ib/II 期试点临床试验,以评估 LDRT 对严重 COVID-19 肺炎患者的安全性、可行性和毒性。此外,我们还评估了 LDRT 后第 3 天氧合改善方面的临床获益,以及避免 LDRT 后第 7 天机械通气的能力。
本研究纳入了聚合酶链反应(PCR)和高分辨率计算机断层扫描(HRCT)均确诊为严重 COVID-19 肺炎、常规治疗(包括地塞米松)无效且需要增加氧气供应的患者。正在接受机械通气的患者被排除在外。符合条件的患者接受单次 100cGy 的全肺照射。如果没有出现任何剂量限制毒性,则计划治疗总共 10 名患者。主要终点是评估 LDRT 后 24 小时内的安全性/可行性和毒性。次要终点是评估 LDRT 在第 3、7、14 和 28 天的疗效。
10 名患者接受了 LDRT。所有(100%)患者均能够在治疗后 24 小时内完成 LDRT,无任何与治疗相关的 SAE。没有接受 LDRT 的患者在 LDRT 后 24 小时内的临床和呼吸状况没有发生任何急性毒性变化。大多数(90%)患者在 LDRT 后 7 天内避免了机械通气。4 名患者(40%)在 3 天内氧需求至少改善了 25%。6 名患者(60%)出院且无需吸氧,而 4 名患者进展并死亡(1 例死于脓毒症,3 例死于细胞因子风暴)。(n=6)中位出院时间为 16.5 天,(n=4)中位死亡时间为 11.0 天。最终死亡的患者与存活出院的患者相比,炎症标志物 Ferritin、CRP 和 D-二聚体升高。
LDRT 是可行的、安全的,并且在治疗严重 COVID-19 肺炎方面具有潜力,包括在常规全身治疗进展的患者中。需要开展更多的 II 期试验来确定最有可能从 LDRT 中获益的患者。