Shih Emily, Aylward Brandon S, Kunkle Sarah, Graziani Grant
Ginger, San Francisco, CA, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2022 Jul 8;6(7):e35352. doi: 10.2196/35352.
Despite the well-known adverse health conditions and negative economic outcomes associated with mental health problems, accessing treatment is difficult due to reasons such as availability and cost. As a solution, digital mental health services have flooded the industry, and new studies are quickly emerging that support their potential as an accessible and cost-effective way to improve mental health outcomes. However, many mental health platforms typically use clinical tools such as the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) or General Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7). Yet, many individuals that seek out care do not have clinical symptomatology and thus, traditional clinical measures may not adequately capture symptom improvement in general well-being. As an alternative, this study used the health-related quality of life (HRQoL) tool from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention "Healthy Days" measure. This subjective measure of well-being is an effective way to capture HRQoL and might be better suited as an outcome measure for treatments that include both clinical and subclinical individuals.
The purpose of this study was to describe changes in HRQoL in clinical and subclinical members assessing virtual care and to examine the association between text-based behavioral coaching and virtual clinical sessions with changes in HRQoL.
A total of 288 members completed the 4-item HRQoL measure at baseline and at 1 month following use of the Ginger on demand behavioral health platform. Baseline anxiety and depression levels were collected using the GAD-7 and PHQ-9, respectively.
Members completed on average 1.92 (SD 2.16) coaching sessions and 0.91 (SD 1.37) clinical sessions during the assessment month. Paired samples t tests revealed significant reductions in the average number of unhealthy mental health days between baseline (mean 16, SD 8.77 days) and follow-up (mean 13.2, SD 9.02 days; t=5.73; P<.001), and in the average number of days adversely impacted (mean 10.9, mean 8.19; t=6.26; P<.001). Both subclinical members (t=3.04; P=.003) and clinical members (t=5.5; P<.001) demonstrated significant improvements through reductions in adversely impacted days over a month. Clinical members also demonstrated significant improvements through reductions in unhealthy mental health days (t=5.82; P<.001). Finally, member engagement with virtual clinical sessions significantly predicted changes in unhealthy mental health days (B=-0.96; P=.04).
To our knowledge, this study is one of the first to use the HRQoL measure as an outcome in an evaluation of a digital behavioral health platform. Using real-world longitudinal data, our preliminary yet promising results show that short-term engagement with virtual care can be an effective means to improve HRQoL for members with subclinical and clinical symptoms. Further follow-up of reported HRQoL over several months is needed.
尽管心理健康问题会带来众所周知的不良健康状况和负面经济后果,但由于可及性和成本等原因,获得治疗存在困难。作为一种解决方案,数字心理健康服务已充斥该行业,并且新的研究迅速涌现,支持其作为一种可及且具成本效益的改善心理健康结果的方式的潜力。然而,许多心理健康平台通常使用诸如患者健康问卷9项版(PHQ - 9)或广泛性焦虑障碍7项版(GAD - 7)等临床工具。然而,许多寻求护理的个体并无临床症状,因此,传统临床测量方法可能无法充分捕捉总体幸福感方面的症状改善情况。作为替代方法,本研究使用了美国疾病控制与预防中心“健康日”测量中的健康相关生活质量(HRQoL)工具。这种幸福感的主观测量方法是捕捉HRQoL的有效方式,可能更适合作为包括临床和亚临床个体在内的治疗的结果测量指标。
本研究的目的是描述评估虚拟护理的临床和亚临床成员中HRQoL的变化,并研究基于文本的行为指导和虚拟临床会话与HRQoL变化之间的关联。
共有288名成员在基线时以及使用按需提供的Ginger行为健康平台1个月后完成了4项HRQoL测量。分别使用GAD - 7和PHQ - 9收集基线焦虑和抑郁水平。
在评估月期间,成员平均完成了1.92次(标准差2.16)指导会话和0.91次(标准差1.37)临床会话。配对样本t检验显示,基线时(平均16天,标准差8.