Schwartz Isabella, Safran Ori, Karniel Naama, Abel Michal, Berko Adina, Seyres Martin, Tsoar Tamir, Portnoy Sigal
Faculty of Medicine, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem 91905, Israel.
Department of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, Hadassah Medical Center, Jerusalem 9765418, Israel.
J Clin Med. 2022 Jul 5;11(13):3919. doi: 10.3390/jcm11133919.
Virtual reality enables the manipulation of a patient's perception, providing additional motivation to real-time biofeedback exercises. We aimed to test the effect of manipulated virtual kinematic intervention on measures of active and passive range of motion (ROM), pain, and disability level in individuals with traumatic stiff shoulder. In a double-blinded study, patients with stiff shoulder following proximal humerus fracture and non-operative treatment were randomly divided into a non-manipulated feedback group (NM-group; = 6) and a manipulated feedback group (M-group; = 7). The shoulder ROM, pain, and disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (DASH) scores were tested at baseline and after 6 sessions, during which the subjects performed shoulder flexion and abduction in front of a graphic visualization of the shoulder angle. The biofeedback provided to the NM-group was the actual shoulder angle while the feedback provided to the M-group was manipulated so that 10° were constantly subtracted from the actual angle detected by the motion capture system. The M-group showed greater improvement in the active flexion ROM ( = 0.046) and DASH scores ( = 0.022). While both groups improved following the real-time virtual feedback intervention, the manipulated intervention provided to the M-group was more beneficial in individuals with traumatic stiff shoulder and should be further tested in other populations with orthopedic injuries.
虚拟现实能够操控患者的感知,为实时生物反馈训练提供额外的动力。我们旨在测试操控性虚拟运动学干预对创伤性肩周炎患者主动和被动活动范围(ROM)、疼痛及残疾程度指标的影响。在一项双盲研究中,肱骨近端骨折且接受非手术治疗后出现肩周炎的患者被随机分为非操控反馈组(NM组;n = 6)和操控反馈组(M组;n = 7)。在基线时以及6次训练后对肩部ROM、疼痛以及手臂、肩部和手部功能障碍(DASH)评分进行测试,在此期间,受试者在肩部角度的图形可视化前进行肩部前屈和外展动作。提供给NM组的生物反馈是实际肩部角度,而提供给M组的反馈则经过操控,使得从运动捕捉系统检测到的实际角度中持续减去10°。M组在主动前屈ROM(P = 0.046)和DASH评分(P = 0.022)方面有更大改善。虽然两组在实时虚拟反馈干预后均有改善,但提供给M组的操控性干预对创伤性肩周炎患者更为有益,应在其他骨科损伤人群中进一步测试。