Raparelli Valeria, Wright Catherine X, Corica Bernadette, Sharma Garima, Lindley Kathryn, Brackett Alexandria, Pilote Louise, Wood Malissa J, Dreyer Rachel P
Department of Translational Medicine, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy; University Centre for Studies on Gender Medicine, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy; Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Internal Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Can J Cardiol. 2022 Dec;38(12):1881-1892. doi: 10.1016/j.cjca.2022.06.025. Epub 2022 Jul 6.
The burden of ischemic heart disease (IHD) is a major health problem worldwide. The detrimental effect of gendered (ie, unevenly distributed between female and male) socioeconomic determinants of health (SDOH) on outcomes has been demonstrated, more so in female individuals. Therefore, addressing SDOH is a priority for the care implementation of patients with IHD. We conducted a scoping review to identify the types of SDOH-tailored interventions tested in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) among IHD patients, and whether the reporting of findings was sex-unbiased. We identified 8 SDOH domains: education, physical environment, health care system, economic stability, social support, sexual orientation, culture/language, and systemic racism. A total of 28 RCTs (2 ongoing) were evaluated. Since the 1990s, 26 RCTs have been conducted, mainly in the Middle East and Asia, and addressed only education, physical environment, health care system, and social support. The 77% of studies focused on patient-education interventions, and around 80% on SDOH-based interventions achieved positive effects on a variety of primary outcome(s). Among the limitations of the conducted RCTs, the most relevant were an overall low participation of female and racial/ethnical minority participants, a lack of sex-stratified analyses, and a missing opportunity of tailoring some SDOH interventions relevant for health. The SDOH-tailored interventions tested so far in RCTs, enrolling predominantly male patients and mainly targeting education and health literacy, were effective in improving outcomes among patients with IHD. Future studies should focus on a wider range of SDOH with an adequate representation of female and minority patients who would most benefit from such interventions.
缺血性心脏病(IHD)的负担是全球主要的健康问题。性别化(即女性和男性之间分布不均)的健康社会经济决定因素(SDOH)对疾病结局的不利影响已得到证实,在女性个体中更为明显。因此,解决SDOH是IHD患者护理实施的优先事项。我们进行了一项范围综述,以确定在IHD患者的随机对照试验(RCT)中测试的SDOH针对性干预措施的类型,以及研究结果的报告是否无性别偏见。我们确定了8个SDOH领域:教育、物理环境、医疗保健系统、经济稳定性、社会支持、性取向、文化/语言和系统性种族主义。共评估了28项RCT(2项正在进行)。自20世纪90年代以来,已进行了26项RCT,主要在中东和亚洲,且仅涉及教育、物理环境、医疗保健系统和社会支持。77%的研究侧重于患者教育干预措施,约80%基于SDOH的干预措施对各种主要结局产生了积极影响。在所进行的RCT的局限性中,最相关的是女性和种族/少数民族参与者总体参与率低、缺乏性别分层分析,以及错失了定制一些与健康相关的SDOH干预措施的机会。迄今为止,在RCT中测试的SDOH针对性干预措施主要纳入男性患者,主要针对教育和健康素养,对改善IHD患者的结局有效。未来的研究应关注更广泛的SDOH领域,要有足够数量的女性和少数族裔患者参与,这些患者将从此类干预措施中受益最多。