Badhiwala Jetan H, Wilson Jefferson R, Kulkarni Abhaya V, Kiss Alexander, Harrop James S, Vaccaro Alexander R, Aarabi Bizhan, Geisler Fred H, Fehlings Michael G
Division of Neurosurgery, Department of Surgery, Management, and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Institute of Health Policy, Management, and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Neurotrauma. 2022 Dec;39(23-24):1654-1664. doi: 10.1089/neu.2022.0145. Epub 2022 Sep 14.
The outcomes of cervical incomplete spinal cord injury (SCI) are heterogeneous. This study sought to dissociate subgroups of cervical incomplete SCI patients with distinct longitudinal temporal profiles of recovery in upper limb motor function. Patients with cervical incomplete SCI (American Spinal Injury Association Impairment Scale [AIS] B-D; C1-C8) were identified from four prospective, multi-center SCI datasets. A group-based trajectory model was fit to longitudinal upper extremity motor scores out to 1 year. Multi-variable multinomial logistic regression was performed to identify features that characterize each trajectory group. A classification system for predicting trajectory group at baseline was developed by recursive partitioning. In total, 801 patients were eligible. Four distinct trajectory groups were identified: 1) "Poor outcome": Severe injury, very minimal recovery; 2) "Moderate recovery": Moderate-to-severe injury, moderate recovery; most recovery occurs by 6 months, with mild, gradual recovery continuing thereafter; 3) "Good recovery": Moderate injury, good recovery; most recovery occurs by 3 months, with mild, gradual recovery continuing thereafter; and 4) "Excellent outcome": Mild injury, recovery to normal/near-normal by 3 months. On adjusted analyses, older age was associated with lower likelihood of "excellent outcome" ( = 0.020). AIS C and D injuries were associated with "moderate recovery," "good recovery," and "excellent outcome" ( < 0.001). Mid-cervical injuries occurred more frequently in "moderate recovery," "good recovery," and "excellent outcome" ( < 0.001) groups. Early surgical decompression (< 24 h) was associated with increased propensity for "good recovery" ( = 0.039) and "excellent outcome" ( = 0.048). A classification model based on recursive partitioning could predict trajectory group using age, AIS grade, and neurological level with an area under the curve of 0.81. Patients with cervical incomplete SCI demonstrate distinct temporal profiles of recovery in upper limb motor function. The trajectory a patient is likely to follow may be predicted at baseline with fair accuracy.
颈髓不完全性脊髓损伤(SCI)的预后具有异质性。本研究旨在区分颈髓不完全性SCI患者的亚组,这些亚组在上肢运动功能恢复方面具有不同的纵向时间特征。从四个前瞻性、多中心SCI数据集中识别出颈髓不完全性SCI患者(美国脊髓损伤协会损伤量表[AIS] B-D;C1-C8)。将基于组的轨迹模型应用于长达1年的纵向上肢运动评分。进行多变量多项逻辑回归以识别表征每个轨迹组的特征。通过递归划分开发了一种在基线时预测轨迹组的分类系统。共有801例患者符合条件。识别出四个不同的轨迹组:1)“预后差”:严重损伤,恢复极少;2)“中度恢复”:中度至重度损伤,中度恢复;大部分恢复在6个月时发生,此后有轻度、逐渐的恢复;3)“良好恢复”:中度损伤,良好恢复;大部分恢复在3个月时发生,此后有轻度、逐渐的恢复;4)“优异预后”:轻度损伤,在3个月时恢复至正常/接近正常。在调整分析中,年龄较大与“优异预后”的可能性较低相关( = 0.020)。AIS C级和D级损伤与“中度恢复”、“良好恢复”和“优异预后”相关( < 0.001)。颈髓中部损伤在“中度恢复”、"良好恢复"和"优异预后"组中更常见( < 0.001)。早期手术减压(< 24小时)与“良好恢复”( = 0.039)和“优异预后”( = 0.048)的倾向增加相关。基于递归划分的分类模型可以使用年龄、AIS分级和神经平面预测轨迹组,曲线下面积为0.81。颈髓不完全性SCI患者在上肢运动功能恢复方面表现出不同的时间特征。患者可能遵循的轨迹在基线时可以有相当准确的预测。