Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology, Radboud Institute of Molecular Life Sciences, Nijmegen, Netherlands.
UZ-UCSF Collaborative Study in Women's Health Zimbabwe, Harare, Zimbabwe.
J Int AIDS Soc. 2022 Jul;25 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):e25914. doi: 10.1002/jia2.25914.
To allow the continued participation of women enrolled in pre-licensure clinical trials who become pregnant, and to potentially enrol pregnant women in clinical trials, non-clinical developmental and reproductive toxicology studies (DART) are essential. Generally during pharmaceutical development, DART studies are conducted late during clinical development, leading to the exclusion of pregnant women from enrolment and withdrawal of women becoming pregnant during pre-licensure trials.
Completing all DART studies prior to or early during the conduct of phase 3 trials (i.e. earlier than current common practice) can accelerate and facilitate the inclusion of women who become pregnant during pre-licensure trials to remain on study drug and to potentially enrol pregnant women more rapidly. Promoting complementary strategies, such as alternative combinations of DART study designs and physiologically based pharmacokinetic modelling, could better inform drug dosing and safety in pregnancy at an earlier stage in drug development. The interpretation of the results of non-clinical DART studies is often complex. Institutional review boards/ethics committees should have access to relevant expertise for interpretation and application of results of non-clinical developmental and reproductive toxicity studies. Clear communication and thorough understanding of non-clinical findings and the overall benefit-risk profile of the product are critical to review protocols and determine if women who become pregnant during a clinical trial could continue on study drug and/or to enrol pregnant women in the trial. The informed consent document should be well written so that participants can make an informed decision to stay on study drug or participate in a trial during pregnancy. Ultimately, the decision to allow women who become pregnant during pre-licensure trials to remain on study will depend on the totality of the evidence and benefit-risk considerations.
We propose that industry completes non-clinical reproductive toxicity studies prior to or early during the conduct of phase 3 trials in HIV drug development, especially for priority agents, and potentially uses alternative DART study design strategies to achieve this goal.
为了允许已参加上市前临床试验且已怀孕的女性继续参与试验,并可能招募孕妇参加临床试验,非临床生殖发育毒性研究(DART)至关重要。一般来说,在药物开发过程中,DART 研究在临床开发后期进行,导致孕妇无法入组,并使正在参加上市前试验的女性退出。
在进行 III 期试验(即在当前常见实践之前更早)之前或早期完成所有 DART 研究,可以加速并促进纳入在上市前试验期间怀孕的女性继续使用研究药物,并可能更快地招募孕妇。推广补充策略,如 DART 研究设计和基于生理学的药代动力学建模的替代组合,可以更早地为药物开发提供有关妊娠期间药物剂量和安全性的信息。非临床 DART 研究结果的解释往往很复杂。机构审查委员会/伦理委员会应能够获得相关专业知识,以解释和应用非临床生殖发育毒性研究的结果。清晰的沟通和对非临床发现和产品整体获益风险概况的全面理解,对于审查方案和确定在临床试验期间怀孕的女性是否可以继续使用研究药物以及是否招募孕妇参加试验至关重要。知情同意书应写得很好,以便参与者能够做出明智的决定,是继续使用研究药物还是在怀孕期间参加试验。最终,允许在上市前试验期间怀孕的女性继续使用研究药物的决定将取决于总体证据和获益风险考虑。
我们建议业界在 HIV 药物开发的 III 期试验进行之前或早期完成非临床生殖毒性研究,特别是对于优先药物,并可能使用替代 DART 研究设计策略来实现这一目标。