Climate & Energy Program, Union of Concerned Scientists, Washington, DC, United States of America.
Center for Science and Democracy, Union of Concerned Scientists, Cambridge, MA, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2022 Jul 20;17(7):e0271026. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0271026. eCollection 2022.
Policies to reduce greenhouse gases associated with electricity generation have been a major focus of public policy in the United States, but their implications for achieving environmental justice among historically overburdened communities inappropriately remains a marginal issue. In this study we address research gaps in historical and current ambient air emissions burdens in environmental justice communities from power plants participating in the Regional Greenhouse Gases Initiative (RGGI), the country's first market-based power sector emissions reduction program. We find that in RGGI states the percentage of people of color that live within 0-6.2 miles from power plants is up to 23.5 percent higher than the percent of the white population that lives within those same distance bands, and the percentage of people living in poverty that live within 0-5 miles from power plants is up to 15.3 percent higher than the percent of the population not living in poverty within those same distance bands. More importantly, the transition from coal to natural gas underway before RGGI formally started resulted in large increases in both the number of electric-generating units burning natural gas and total net generation from natural gas in environmental justice communities hosting electric-generating units, compared to other communities. Our findings indicate that power sector carbon mitigation policies' focusing on aggregate emissions reductions have largely benefitted non-environmental justice communities and have not redressed the fundamental problem of disparities in pollutant burdens between EJ and non-EJ communities. These must be directly addressed in climate change and carbon emissions mitigation policy.
减少与发电相关的温室气体的政策一直是美国公共政策的主要焦点,但它们对实现历史上负担过重的环境正义社区的环境正义的影响仍然是一个边缘问题。在这项研究中,我们解决了参与区域温室气体倡议(RGGI)的发电厂的环境正义社区的历史和当前环境空气排放负担方面的研究空白,该倡议是美国第一个基于市场的电力部门减排计划。我们发现,在 RGGI 州,居住在距离发电厂 0-6.2 英里范围内的有色人种的比例比居住在相同距离带内的白人人口的比例高 23.5%,而居住在距离发电厂 0-5 英里范围内的贫困人口的比例比生活在同一距离带内的非贫困人口的比例高 15.3%。更重要的是,在 RGGI 正式启动之前,从煤炭向天然气的过渡导致在环境正义社区中燃烧天然气的发电单元数量和天然气总净发电量都大大增加,与其他社区相比。我们的研究结果表明,电力部门碳减排政策侧重于总体排放量减少,主要使非环境正义社区受益,并没有解决环境正义社区和非环境正义社区之间污染物负担差异的根本问题。这些问题必须在气候变化和碳排放缓解政策中直接解决。