Krahn Steven L
Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA.
Consortium for Risk Evaluation with Stakeholder Participation (CRESP), Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA.
Risk Anal. 2022 Nov;42(11):2421-2439. doi: 10.1111/risa.13986. Epub 2022 Jul 24.
Regulators and policymakers are routinely challenged with explaining complex concepts concerning risk. Part of the challenge is helping external and internal stakeholders to understand the context behind risk-related information and decisions. This paper will describe the historical evolution of the safety and regulatory framework for an important category in the nuclear industry-defense nuclear facilities owned and operated by the US Department of Energy. In parallel with describing this evolution, three major events which occurred external to the complex of defense nuclear facilities will be summarized, and their impact on the maturation of the Department's safety and regulatory framework will be discussed. Finally, integrated with these two threads of discussion will be a chronicle of the changing set of involved organizations and the expanding set of external stakeholders involved in risk decisions-and therefore, the risk communications ecosystem surrounding defense nuclear facilities. It will be noted that this system was once describable as a classic "iron triangle," but now has progressed to a complex network of federal and state organizations, numerous congressional committees, and expanding sets of external stakeholders. It is hoped that a comprehensive discussion of the context of risk assessment in the defense nuclear facilities complex-addressing historical insights, organizational evolution, and the maturing structure of regulation-will provide enhanced opportunities for building trust and understanding in this complex environment.
监管机构和政策制定者经常面临解释与风险相关的复杂概念的挑战。挑战的一部分在于帮助外部和内部利益相关者理解风险相关信息和决策背后的背景。本文将描述核工业中一个重要类别——美国能源部拥有和运营的国防核设施的安全与监管框架的历史演变。在描述这一演变的同时,将总结在国防核设施建筑群外部发生的三件重大事件,并讨论它们对该部门安全与监管框架成熟度的影响。最后,将这两条讨论线索结合起来的将是一份关于参与风险决策的相关组织不断变化的情况以及参与国防核设施风险决策的外部利益相关者群体不断扩大的记录——因此,也就是围绕国防核设施的风险沟通生态系统。需要指出的是,这个系统曾经可以被描述为一个经典的“铁三角”,但现在已经发展成为一个由联邦和州组织、众多国会委员会以及不断扩大的外部利益相关者群体组成的复杂网络。希望对国防核设施建筑群中风险评估背景的全面讨论——涉及历史见解、组织演变和监管的成熟结构——将为在这个复杂环境中建立信任和理解提供更多机会。