School of Psychology, Faculty of Science, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Department of Psychological Medicine, Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
J Adolesc. 2022 Oct;94(7):969-980. doi: 10.1002/jad.12078. Epub 2022 Jul 26.
Self-harm is a significant public health issue affecting school communities, students, and families. The school is an ideal environment for early intervention and prevention. This study aimed to explore the views of young people and stakeholders on how school staff should support students who self-harm in the context of developing accessible and acceptable guidelines.
The study was nested within a larger Delphi study conducted in New Zealand. Two panels were asked to provide reflection in open text boxes in two questionnaires on how school staff can support students who self-harm. The youth panel included 22 participants between 16 and 25 years, and 81.8% identified as female and 18.3% as male. The stakeholder panel (e.g., school staff) included 27 participants over 25 years, and 63.0% identified as female, and 37.0% as male. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis to identify key themes.
Eight themes were identified; (1) an approach that prioritizes trust, (2) an approach that recognizes students' agency, (3) an individually tailored approach, (4) a whole-school approach, (5) an approach that recognizes role boundaries, (6) an approach that prioritizes safety, (7) a nonpunitive approach, and (8) an appropriately-resourced approach.
The eight themes identified highlighted ineffective practices in response to self-harm in schools. The eight themes provide solutions to these practices. Our findings highlighted four recommendations that address ineffective management approaches in response to students who self-harm. These recommendations included using a student-centered approach, a whole-school approach, avoiding punitive approaches, and providing adequate resourcing to schools.
自残是一个严重的公共卫生问题,影响着学校社区、学生和家庭。学校是早期干预和预防自残行为的理想环境。本研究旨在探讨年轻人和利益相关者对学校工作人员在制定可及和可接受的指导方针的背景下应如何支持自残学生的看法。
该研究嵌套在新西兰进行的一项更大的德尔菲研究中。两个小组被要求在两份问卷的开放文本框中提供关于学校工作人员如何支持自残学生的意见。青年小组包括 22 名年龄在 16 至 25 岁之间的参与者,其中 81.8%为女性,18.3%为男性。利益相关者小组(如学校工作人员)包括 27 名 25 岁以上的参与者,其中 63.0%为女性,37.0%为男性。使用主题分析对数据进行分析,以确定关键主题。
确定了 8 个主题;(1)优先考虑信任的方法,(2)承认学生代理权的方法,(3)量身定制的方法,(4)全校方法,(5)承认角色界限的方法,(6)优先考虑安全的方法,(7)非惩罚性方法,(8)资源充足的方法。
确定的 8 个主题突出了学校应对自残行为的无效做法。这 8 个主题提供了这些做法的解决方案。我们的研究结果强调了四项建议,这些建议旨在解决对自残学生管理不善的问题。这些建议包括采用以学生为中心的方法、全校方法、避免惩罚性方法和为学校提供充足的资源。