Green David B, Kilgore Joseph A, Bender Shane A, Daniels Robert J, Gunzler Douglas D, Vrabec Tina L, Bhadra Niloy
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, MetroHealth Medical Center, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, School of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Bioelectron Med. 2022 Jul 27;8(1):11. doi: 10.1186/s42234-022-00093-z.
KiloHertz frequency alternating current waveforms produce conduction block in peripheral nerves. It is not clearly known how the waveform shape affects block outcomes, and if waveform effects are frequency dependent. We determined the effects of waveform shape using two types of electrodes.
Acute in-vivo experiments were performed on 12 rats. Bipolar electrodes were used to electrically block motor nerve impulses in the sciatic nerve, as measured using force output from the gastrocnemius muscle. Three blocking waveforms were delivered (sinusoidal, square and triangular) at 6 frequencies (10-60 kHz). Bare platinum electrodes were compared with carbon black coated electrodes. We determined the minimum amplitude that could completely block motor nerve conduction (block threshold), and measured properties of the onset response, which is a transient period of nerve activation at the start of block. In-vivo results were compared with computational modeling conducted using the NEURON simulation environment using a nerve membrane model modified for stimulation in the kilohertz frequency range.
For the majority of parameters, in-vivo testing and simulations showed similar results: Block thresholds increased linearly with frequency for all three waveforms. Block thresholds were significantly different between waveforms; lowest for the square waveform and highest for triangular waveform. When converted to charge per cycle, square waveforms required the maximum charge per phase, and triangular waveforms the least. Onset parameters were affected by blocking frequency but not by waveform shape. Electrode comparisons were performed only in-vivo. Electrodes with carbon black coatings gave significantly lower block thresholds and reduced onset responses across all blocking frequencies. For 10 and 20 kHz, carbon black coating significantly reduced the charge required for nerve block.
We conclude that both sinusoidal and square waveforms at frequencies of 20 kHz or higher would be optimal. Future investigation of carbon black or other high charge capacity electrodes may be useful in achieving block with lower BTs and onsets. These findings will be of importance for designing clinical nerve block systems.
千赫兹频率的交流电流波形可在外周神经中产生传导阻滞。目前尚不清楚波形形状如何影响阻滞结果,以及波形效应是否与频率相关。我们使用两种类型的电极确定了波形形状的影响。
对12只大鼠进行急性体内实验。使用双极电极电刺激坐骨神经中的运动神经冲动,通过腓肠肌的力输出进行测量。在6个频率(10 - 60kHz)下施加三种阻滞波形(正弦波、方波和三角波)。将裸铂电极与炭黑涂层电极进行比较。我们确定了能够完全阻断运动神经传导的最小幅度(阻滞阈值),并测量了起始反应的特性,起始反应是阻滞开始时神经激活的一个短暂时期。将体内实验结果与使用NEURON模拟环境进行的计算建模结果进行比较,该模型使用了针对千赫兹频率范围刺激进行修改的神经膜模型。
对于大多数参数,体内测试和模拟结果相似:所有三种波形的阻滞阈值均随频率线性增加。不同波形之间的阻滞阈值存在显著差异;方波最低,三角波最高。当转换为每周期电荷量时,方波每相所需电荷量最大,三角波最少。起始参数受阻滞频率影响,但不受波形形状影响。仅在体内进行了电极比较。炭黑涂层电极在所有阻滞频率下均给出了显著更低的阻滞阈值,并降低了起始反应。对于10kHz和20kHz,炭黑涂层显著降低了神经阻滞所需的电荷量。
我们得出结论,20kHz及以上频率的正弦波和方波都是最佳的。未来对炭黑或其他高电荷容量电极的研究可能有助于实现更低的阻滞阈值和起始反应。这些发现对于设计临床神经阻滞系统具有重要意义。