Jiang Simon W, Flynn Michael Seth, Kwock Jeffery T, Nicholas Matilda W
Department of Dermatology Duke University School of Medicine Durham, NC United States.
JMIR Dermatol. 2022 Jul 18;5(3):e37517. doi: 10.2196/37517. eCollection 2022 Jul-Sep.
Store-and-forward (SAF) teledermatology uses electronically stored information, including patient photographs and demographic information, for clinical decision-making asynchronous to the patient encounter. The integration of SAF teledermatology into clinical practice has been increasing in recent years, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite this growth, data regarding the outcomes of SAF teledermatology are limited. A key distinction among current literature involves comparing the quality and utility of images obtained by patients and trained clinicians, as these metrics may vary by the clinical expertise of the photographer.
This narrative literature review aimed to characterize the outcomes of SAF teledermatology through the lens of patient- versus clinician-initiated photography and highlight important future directions for and challenges of the field.
A literature search of peer-reviewed research was performed between February and April 2021. Key search terms included , , , , , , , , , and . Only studies published after 2001 in English were included. In total, 47 studies were identified from the PubMed electronic database and Google Scholar after omitting duplicate articles.
Image quality and diagnostic concordance are generally lower and more variable with patient-submitted images, which may impact their decision-making utility. SAF teledermatology can improve the efficiency of and access to care when photographs are taken by either clinicians or patients. The clinical outcomes of clinician-submitted images are comparable to those of in-person visits in the few studies that have investigated these outcomes. Coinciding with the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, asynchronous teledermatology helped minimize unnecessary in-person visits in the outpatient setting, as many uncomplicated conditions could be adequately managed remotely via images captured by patients and referring clinicians. For the inpatient setting, SAF teledermatology minimized unnecessary contact during dermatology consultations, although current studies are limited by the heterogeneity of their outcomes.
In general, photographs taken by trained clinicians are higher quality and have better and more relevant diagnostic and clinical outcomes. SAF teledermatology helped clinicians avoid unnecessary physical contact with patients in the outpatient and inpatient settings during the COVID-19 pandemic. Asynchronous teledermatology will likely play a greater role in the future as SAF images become integrated into synchronous teledermatology workflows. However, the obstacles summarized in this review should be addressed before its widespread implementation into clinical practice.
存储转发(SAF)远程皮肤病学利用电子存储的信息,包括患者照片和人口统计学信息,用于与患者就诊不同步的临床决策。近年来,SAF远程皮肤病学在临床实践中的整合一直在增加,尤其是在新冠疫情期间。尽管有这种增长,但关于SAF远程皮肤病学结果的数据有限。当前文献的一个关键区别在于比较患者和受过培训的临床医生所获得图像的质量和效用,因为这些指标可能因拍摄者的临床专业知识而异。
本叙述性文献综述旨在通过患者与临床医生发起摄影的视角来描述SAF远程皮肤病学的结果,并突出该领域重要的未来方向和挑战。
于2021年2月至4月对同行评审研究进行文献检索。关键检索词包括……(此处原文未完整列出检索词)。仅纳入2001年后发表的英文研究。在剔除重复文章后,从PubMed电子数据库和谷歌学术中总共识别出47项研究。
患者提交的图像的图像质量和诊断一致性通常较低且更具变异性,这可能会影响其决策效用。当由临床医生或患者拍摄照片时,SAF远程皮肤病学可以提高医疗效率并增加就医机会。在少数研究这些结果的研究中,临床医生提交图像的临床结果与面对面就诊的结果相当。与新冠疫情的爆发同时,异步远程皮肤病学有助于在门诊环境中尽量减少不必要的面对面就诊,因为许多简单病症可以通过患者和转诊临床医生拍摄的图像进行远程充分管理。对于住院环境,SAF远程皮肤病学在皮肤科会诊期间尽量减少了不必要的接触,尽管目前的研究受到其结果异质性的限制。
一般来说,受过培训的临床医生拍摄的照片质量更高,具有更好且更相关的诊断和临床结果。在新冠疫情期间,SAF远程皮肤病学帮助临床医生在门诊和住院环境中避免与患者进行不必要的身体接触。随着SAF图像被整合到同步远程皮肤病学工作流程中,异步远程皮肤病学未来可能会发挥更大作用。然而,在将其广泛应用于临床实践之前应解决本综述中总结的障碍。