Kim William, Sivesind Torunn
Department of Dermatology, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO, United States.
JMIR Dermatol. 2022 Jan 26;5(1):e33361. doi: 10.2196/33361.
Medical photography is used extensively in dermatology to record disease progression, measure treatment response, and help teach patients about skin disease; such photos are also commonly utilized in teledermatology, medical education, research, and medical reference websites. Understanding patient perceptions of medical photographs obtained during dermatologic care in the clinic or hospital setting is critical to enable the delivery of high-quality, patient-centered medical care.
The aims of this study were to elucidate patient perceptions of skin photos in dermatology and to explore possible next steps in improving the patient experience with medical photography in the hospital or clinic setting.
A scoping review of the literature was performed using the PubMed database, with clinic- or hospital-based full-text publications in English spanning the last 10 years considered for inclusion.
The majority of included studies (10/11, 91%) found positive patient attitudes toward medical photographs. The majority of patients (1197/1511, 79.2%) felt that medical photographs could improve medical care in the clinic setting. Written consent detailing all photo uses, including secondary uses (such as research or teaching), was preferred, apart from in 1 study. Patients preferred or found it acceptable for the photographer of their medical photos to be a physician (1301/1444, 90.1%). Clinic-owned cameras with departmental record storage were the preferred modality. Latinx and African American patients expressed less trust in the utility of medical photographs to improve care, compared with Asian and White patients. The minimal number of available publications on this topic and the inclusion of articles older than 5 years are limitations, since patient perceptions of medical photography may have rapidly changed during this time span, particularly in light of the COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent increase in teledermatology visits.
Patients reported positive perceptions of dermatologic photography for improving their medical care. Ethnic disparities in patient perceptions require further exploration to better elucidate nuances and develop interventions to improve the experience of marginalized patients. Building patient trust in nonphysician photographers may enhance clinic efficiency. Although clinic-owned cameras are well-accepted by patients, improved patient education surrounding the safety of electronic medical record phone applications is needed.
医学摄影在皮肤科被广泛用于记录疾病进展、衡量治疗反应以及帮助患者了解皮肤病;此类照片也常用于远程皮肤病学、医学教育、研究以及医学参考网站。了解患者对在诊所或医院环境中皮肤科护理期间所拍摄医学照片的看法,对于提供高质量的、以患者为中心的医疗护理至关重要。
本研究的目的是阐明患者对皮肤科皮肤照片的看法,并探索在医院或诊所环境中改善患者医学摄影体验的可能后续步骤。
使用PubMed数据库对文献进行范围综述,纳入过去10年以英文发表的基于诊所或医院的全文出版物。
大多数纳入研究(10/11,91%)发现患者对医学照片持积极态度。大多数患者(1197/1511,79.2%)认为医学照片可以改善诊所环境中的医疗护理。除了一项研究外,患者更倾向于获得详细说明所有照片用途(包括二次使用,如研究或教学)的书面同意。患者更倾向于或认为其医学照片的拍摄者为医生是可以接受的(1301/1444,90.1%)。诊所拥有的配备科室记录存储功能的相机是首选方式。与亚洲和白人患者相比,拉丁裔和非裔美国患者对医学照片改善护理的效用表达出较少的信任。关于该主题的可用出版物数量极少,且纳入了超过5年的文章,这是局限性所在,因为在此时间段内患者对医学摄影的看法可能已迅速改变,尤其是鉴于新冠疫情以及随后远程皮肤病学就诊的增加。
患者报告了对皮肤科摄影改善其医疗护理的积极看法。患者看法中的种族差异需要进一步探索,以更好地阐明细微差别并制定干预措施,以改善边缘化患者的体验。建立患者对非医生摄影师的信任可能会提高诊所效率。尽管诊所拥有的相机很受患者欢迎,但需要围绕电子病历手机应用程序的安全性加强患者教育。