Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of Washington School of Medicine.
Department of Psychology, Florida International University.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2022 Jul;90(7):545-558. doi: 10.1037/ccp0000743.
Almost no studies identify mediators of psychosocial interventions for attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)-largely due to design limitations. Understanding mediators can promote streamlined interventions in usual care (UC) settings. When individual studies are insufficient to pursue complex questions, integrative data analysis (IDA) allows researchers to pool raw data from multiple studies to produce cumulative scientific knowledge.
We leveraged IDA to pool and harmonize data from four randomized controlled trials of ADHD psychosocial treatment (N = 854) with three time points. Linear growth curve analyses examined the impact of four psychosocial treatment conditions on ADHD symptom outcomes and five candidate mediators (compared to no treatment). To test mediation, we examined whether treatment condition predicted linear growth in the mediator at posttreatment, and if the mediator predicted linear growth in the outcome at follow-up.
Compared to no treatment, engagement-focused parent-teen treatment (d = .43-.72; Supporting Teens' Autonomy Daily [STAND]) and community-based usual care (d = .54-.99) led to greatest reductions in parent-rated ADHD symptoms, followed by the Summer Treatment Program-Adolescent (d = .29-.30; STP-A) and standard behavioral parent training + organization skills training (d = .26-.31; BPT/OST). Improvements in organization, time management, and planning skills mediated outcome for all treatments. BPT/OST and STP-A prevented deterioration of social skills, in turn mitigating escalation of ADHD symptoms. Improvements in parent-teen communication skills mediated outcome for STAND, BPT/OST, and the STP-A. Parent contingency management and disruptive classroom behavior were not treatment mediators.
Psychosocial treatments for adolescent ADHD primarily improve ADHD symptoms through development of teen organization, time management (OTP), and parent-teen communication skills, as well as slowing deterioration of social skills. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
几乎没有研究确定针对注意力缺陷/多动障碍(ADHD)的心理社会干预的中介因素——这主要是由于设计上的限制。了解中介因素可以促进在常规护理(UC)环境中进行简化的干预。当个体研究不足以解决复杂问题时,综合数据分析(IDA)允许研究人员从多个研究中汇集原始数据,以产生累积的科学知识。
我们利用 IDA 汇集和协调了四项 ADHD 心理社会治疗的随机对照试验(N = 854)的数据,这些试验有三个时间点。线性增长曲线分析考察了四种心理社会治疗条件对 ADHD 症状结果和五个候选中介因素(与无治疗相比)的影响。为了检验中介作用,我们检验了治疗条件是否预测治疗后中介因素的线性增长,以及中介因素是否预测随访时结果的线性增长。
与无治疗相比,以参与为重点的家长-青少年治疗(d =.43-.72;支持青少年日常自主性[STAND])和基于社区的常规护理(d =.54-.99)导致父母报告的 ADHD 症状减少最多,其次是暑期治疗计划-青少年(d =.29-.30;STP-A)和标准行为父母培训+组织技能训练(d =.26-.31;BPT/OST)。组织、时间管理和计划技能的改善为所有治疗都中介了结果。BPT/OST 和 STP-A 防止了社交技能的恶化,从而减轻了 ADHD 症状的恶化。家长-青少年沟通技能的改善中介了 STAND、BPT/OST 和 STP-A 的结果。家长的条件管理和课堂破坏行为不是治疗中介。
青少年 ADHD 的心理社会治疗主要通过青少年组织、时间管理(OTP)和家长-青少年沟通技能的发展,以及减缓社交技能的恶化,来改善 ADHD 症状。