Morton Sarah, Curran Megan, Barry O'Gorman Mary
School of Social Policy, Social Work and Social Justice, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Center on Poverty and Social Policy, School of Social Work, Columbia University, New York, NY, United States.
Front Psychiatry. 2022 Jul 12;13:892849. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.892849. eCollection 2022.
The long-term impacts of Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are of increasing interest to researchers and practitioners, including the effectiveness of screening for ACEs to improve health and social outcomes. Despite a focus on implementing such practices, there has been little focus on ACEs experiences for women experiencing domestic violence and substance use, or consideration of practice responses around ACEs routine enquiry for domestic violence and related services. The Irish study discussed in this paper used an action research approach to implement ACEs routine enquiry within a domestic violence service for women accessing the service ( = 60), while also utilizing co-operative inquiry groups for practitioners both within the organization ( = 10) and with those working in associated fields of infant mental health, child protection, substance misuse and welfare and community support ( = 7). Of the 60 women who completed the ACEs routine enquiry in the study, over one-half (58 per cent) reported experiencing at least two ACEs in their childhood, including one-third of all respondents reporting experiencing four or more; service users reported significant levels of overlap between direct child maltreatment and adverse home environments. Reported parental substance misuse with the home environment was substantially higher than in general population studies. These findings offered early indications of both ACEs prevalence as well the types of ACEs that most define the experiences of the women presenting to a domestic violence service that supports women with substance misuse and other related issues. This paper discusses the ways in which the co-operative inquiry groups used this information and other processes to enhance practitioner, organizational, and inter-agency understanding and service responses. The practitioners felt that this form of ACEs routine enquiry, while not an end in itself, was a useful tool to engage women in conversations about trauma and intergenerational patterns and a basis for developing trauma-informed interventions. We conclude with discussion about: considerations of the risks of "individualizing" women's traumatic experiences; skills and supports for practitioners; and resource implications.
不良童年经历(ACEs)的长期影响越来越受到研究人员和从业者的关注,包括筛查ACEs以改善健康和社会结果的有效性。尽管重点在于实施此类做法,但对于遭受家庭暴力和药物滥用的女性的ACEs经历关注甚少,也未考虑围绕家庭暴力和相关服务的ACEs常规询问的实践应对措施。本文所讨论的爱尔兰研究采用行动研究方法,在为寻求服务的女性提供家庭暴力服务的机构内实施ACEs常规询问( = 60),同时还为该组织内部的从业者( = 10)以及从事婴儿心理健康、儿童保护、药物滥用、福利和社区支持等相关领域工作的人员( = 7)组建了合作探究小组。在该研究中完成ACEs常规询问的60名女性中,超过一半(58%)报告称童年时期至少经历过两次ACEs,包括三分之一的受访者报告经历过四次或更多;服务使用者报告称直接的儿童虐待与不良家庭环境之间存在显著重叠。报告的父母药物滥用与家庭环境的情况显著高于一般人群研究。这些发现初步表明了ACEs的患病率以及最能界定向支持有药物滥用和其他相关问题女性的家庭暴力服务机构求助的女性经历的ACEs类型。本文讨论了合作探究小组利用这些信息和其他流程来增强从业者、组织和机构间理解及服务应对的方式。从业者认为,这种形式的ACEs常规询问虽然本身并非目的,但却是促使女性参与有关创伤和代际模式对话的有用工具,也是制定创伤知情干预措施的基础。我们最后讨论了:对“个体化”女性创伤经历风险的考量;对从业者的技能和支持;以及资源影响。