Moudi Zahra, Tabatabaei Seyed Mehdi, Share Mollashahi Sedighe, Zaboli Maryam
Department of Midwifery, Pregnancy Health Research Center, Zahedan University of Medical Sciences, Zahedan, Iran.
Department of Statistic and Epidemiology, Zahedan University of Medical Sciences, Iran.
J Family Reprod Health. 2022 Mar;16(1):67-77. doi: 10.18502/jfrh.v16i1.8596.
It is a fact that coronavirus disease of 2019 (COVID-19) infection mortality rate is high, but the question is "what is the role of other factors in maternal death with COVID-19?" The present study aimed to understand the factors that prevent women from timely use of healthcare services and also the potential weaknesses of the healthcare system that cause the lack of quality healthcare services for women. This case-series study was performed in the southeast of Iran. In total, 12 cases of maternal deaths attributed to COVID-19 were identified through the Iranian Maternal Mortality Surveillance System. The required information was collected through existing verbal autopsy data sets. In some cases, the family members had to be re-contacted and healthcare workers were asked to supply the missing information. The root cause analysis method was employed for data analysis. From March 2020 to March 2021, the deaths of 12 women were attributed to COVID-19. The majority of these women lived in rural areas (58%) and had a secondary school education level or less (83.3%). The contributing factors were divided into three categories: barriers at the community level (no prenatal care, lack of trust, lack of recognition of the severity of disease, and attribution of symptoms to something else), at the primary health system level, and at the hospital level (fear of staff of being infected, non-compliance with guidelines, lack of team working, and problem with telehealth). The socio-cultural context and unmet healthcare needs hinder the utilization of available services. Moreover, factors at the level of the healthcare system prevent the timely detection and referral of women with COVID-19 to receive quality healthcare services. Using telehealth also did not help to appropriately triage pregnant women.
2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)感染死亡率很高,这是一个事实,但问题是“在COVID-19导致的孕产妇死亡中,其他因素起到了什么作用?”本研究旨在了解阻碍女性及时利用医疗服务的因素,以及导致女性缺乏优质医疗服务的医疗系统潜在弱点。 这项病例系列研究在伊朗东南部进行。通过伊朗孕产妇死亡监测系统,共确定了12例归因于COVID-19的孕产妇死亡病例。所需信息通过现有的口头尸检数据集收集。在某些情况下,不得不再次联系家庭成员,并要求医护人员提供缺失的信息。采用根本原因分析法进行数据分析。 从2020年3月到2021年3月,12名女性的死亡归因于COVID-19。这些女性大多生活在农村地区(58%),教育水平为中学及以下(83.3%)。促成因素分为三类:社区层面的障碍(无产前护理、缺乏信任、未认识到疾病的严重性以及将症状归因于其他原因)、初级卫生系统层面的障碍以及医院层面的障碍(医护人员担心被感染问题、不遵守指南、缺乏团队协作以及远程医疗问题)。社会文化背景和未满足的医疗需求阻碍了现有服务的利用。此外,医疗系统层面的因素妨碍了对COVID-19感染女性的及时发现和转诊,使其无法获得优质医疗服务。使用远程医疗也无助于对孕妇进行适当的分诊。