Population analysis profiling: is it still the gold standard for the determination of heteroresistance in carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae?

Heteroresistance is the phenomenon wherein subpopulations of presumed isogenic bacteria show varied antibiotic susceptibilities, and the current gold standard for the determination of heteroresistance is population analysis profiling (PAP). However, when conducting PAP to confirm carbapenem heteroresistance in Enterobacteriaceae, the authors found some isolates that did not seem to be heteroresistant, despite meeting PAP criteria. This article elaborates on the validity of PAP for the determination of heteroresistance, especially among carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae (CPE). Bacterial cells that were originally non-viable on selective agar supplemented with a high concentration of meropenem were found to be occasionally viable, likely due to the hydrolysis of carbapenems by carbapenemases produced by dying cells, mimicking the emergence of subpopulations with enhanced resistance. As such, PAP for CPE is highly affected by carbapenemases produced by dying populations, and may not detect heterogeneity in carbapenem resistance appropriately among seemingly isogenic clones.