Infection Biology Laboratory, Department of Medicine and Life Sciences, Universitat Pompeu Fabra (UPF), Barcelona, Spain.
Instituto Oncologico Dr Rosell, Hospital Quiron-Dexeus Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Front Immunol. 2022 Jul 5;13:908108. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2022.908108. eCollection 2022.
Cancer patients (CPs) have been identified as particularly vulnerable to SARS-CoV-2 infection, and therefore are a priority group for receiving COVID-19 vaccination. From the patients with advanced solid tumors, about 20% respond very efficiently to immunotherapy with anti-PD1/PD-L1 antibodies and achieve long lasting cancer responses. It is unclear whether an efficient cancer-specific immune response may also correlate with an efficient response upon COVID-19 vaccination. Here, we explored the antiviral immune response to the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccine BNT162b2 in a group of 11 long-lasting cancer immunotherapy responders. We analysed the development of SARS-CoV-2-specific IgG serum antibodies, virus neutralizing capacities and T cell responses. Control groups included patients treated with adjuvant cancer immunotherapy (IMT, cohort B), CPs not treated with immunotherapy (no-IMT, cohort C) and healthy controls (cohort A). The median ELISA IgG titers significantly increased after the prime-boost COVID vaccine regimen in all cohorts (Cohort A: pre-vaccine = 900 (100-2700), 3 weeks (w) post-boost = 24300 (2700-72900); Cohort B: pre-vaccine = 300 (100-2700), 3 w post-boost = 8100 (300-72900); Cohort C: pre-vaccine = 500 (100-2700), 3 w post-boost = 24300 (300-72900)). However, at the 3 w post-prime time-point, only the healthy control group showed a statistically significant increase in antibody levels (Cohort A = 8100 (900-8100); Cohort B = 900 (300-8100); Cohort C = 900 (300-8100)) (P < 0.05). Strikingly, while all healthy controls generated high-level antibody responses after the complete prime-boost regimen (Cohort A = 15/15 (100%), not all CPs behaved alike [Cohort B= 12/14 (84'6%); Cohort C= 5/6 (83%)]. Their responses, including those of the long-lasting immunotherapy responders, were more variable (Cohort A: 3 w post-boost (median nAb titers = 95.32 (84.09-96.93), median Spike-specific IFN-γ response = 64 (24-150); Cohort B: 3 w post-boost (median nAb titers = 85.62 (8.22-97.19), median Spike-specific IFN-γ response (28 (1-372); Cohort C: 3 w post-boost (median nAb titers = 95.87 (11.8-97.3), median Spike-specific IFN-γ response = 67 (20-84)). Two long-lasting cancer responders did not respond properly to the prime-boost vaccination and did not generate S-specific IgGs, neutralizing antibodies or virus-specific T cells, although their cancer immune control persisted for years. Thus, although mRNA-based vaccines can induce both antibody and T cell responses in CPs, the immune response to COVID vaccination is independent of the capacity to develop an efficient anti-cancer immune response to anti PD-1/PD-L1 antibodies.
癌症患者(CPs)被认为特别容易感染 SARS-CoV-2,因此是接种 COVID-19 疫苗的优先群体。在晚期实体瘤患者中,约 20%的患者对 PD-1/PD-L1 抗体的免疫治疗非常有效,并实现了长期的癌症缓解。目前尚不清楚有效的癌症特异性免疫反应是否也与 COVID-19 疫苗接种后的有效反应相关。在这里,我们研究了一组 11 名长期癌症免疫治疗应答者对基于 mRNA 的 COVID-19 疫苗 BNT162b2 的抗病毒免疫反应。我们分析了 SARS-CoV-2 特异性 IgG 血清抗体、病毒中和能力和 T 细胞反应的发展。对照组包括接受辅助癌症免疫治疗(IMT,队列 B)的患者、未接受免疫治疗的 CPs(无 IMT,队列 C)和健康对照(队列 A)。所有队列在 COVID 疫苗接种方案的基础免疫和加强免疫后,ELISA IgG 滴度中位数均显著增加(队列 A:基础免疫前=900(100-2700),加强免疫后 3 周=24300(2700-72900);队列 B:基础免疫前=300(100-2700),加强免疫后 3 周=8100(300-72900);队列 C:基础免疫前=500(100-2700),加强免疫后 3 周=24300(300-72900))。然而,在基础免疫后 3 周的时间点,只有健康对照组的抗体水平有统计学意义的增加(队列 A=8100(900-8100);队列 B=900(300-8100);队列 C=900(300-8100))(P<0.05)。引人注目的是,虽然所有健康对照者在完全基础免疫和加强免疫方案后都产生了高水平的抗体反应(队列 A=15/15(100%),但并非所有 CPs 的反应都相同[队列 B=12/14(84.6%);队列 C=5/6(83%)]。他们的反应,包括长期免疫治疗应答者的反应,更加多变(队列 A:加强免疫后 3 周(中位数 nAb 滴度=95.32(84.09-96.93),中位数 Spike 特异性 IFN-γ 反应=64(24-150);队列 B:加强免疫后 3 周(中位数 nAb 滴度=85.62(8.22-97.19),中位数 Spike 特异性 IFN-γ 反应(28(1-372);队列 C:加强免疫后 3 周(中位数 nAb 滴度=95.87(11.8-97.3),中位数 Spike 特异性 IFN-γ 反应=67(20-84))。两名长期癌症应答者对基础免疫和加强免疫接种反应不佳,没有产生 S 特异性 IgG、中和抗体或病毒特异性 T 细胞,尽管他们的癌症免疫控制持续了多年。因此,尽管基于 mRNA 的疫苗可以在 CPs 中诱导抗体和 T 细胞反应,但 COVID 疫苗接种的免疫反应与对 PD-1/PD-L1 抗体产生有效癌症免疫反应的能力无关。