Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
Department of Neurological Surgery, University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
World Neurosurg. 2022 Nov;167:222-228.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2022.07.091. Epub 2022 Jul 31.
Following spinal fusion surgery, routine imaging is often obtained in all patients regardless of clinical presentation. Such routine imaging may include x-ray, computed tomography, or magnetic resonance imaging studies in both the immediate postoperative period and after discharge. The clinical utility of this practice is questionable. Our goal is to assess the existing literature for evidence of impact on clinical care from routine radiographic surveillance following spinal fusion.
A systematic search of Embase, Scopus, PubMed, Cochrane, and Ovid databases was performed for studies investigating postoperative imaging following spinal fusion surgery. Studies were analyzed for imaging findings and rates of change in management due to imaging.
In total, the review identified 9 studies that separated data by unique patient or by unique clinic visits. The 4 studies reporting per-patient data totaled 475 patients with 328 (69%) receiving routine imaging. Among these, 28 (8.5%) patients had abnormal routine findings with no patients having a change to their clinical course. Of the 5 studies that reported clinic visit data, 3119 patient visits were included with 2365 (76%) clinic visits accompanied by imaging. Across these 5 studies, 146 (6.2%) visits noted abnormal imaging with only 12 (0.5%) subsequent management changes.
Our analysis found that routine imaging after spinal fusion surgery had no direct benefit on clinical management. The utility of baseline imaging for long-term comparison and medicolegal concerns were not studied and remain up to the provider's judgment. Further research is necessary to identify optimal imaging criteria following spinal fusion surgery.
脊柱融合手术后,无论临床表现如何,通常都会对所有患者进行常规影像学检查。这种常规影像学检查可能包括术后即刻和出院后的 X 光、计算机断层扫描或磁共振成像研究。这种常规做法的临床实用性是值得怀疑的。我们的目标是评估现有文献,以评估脊柱融合术后常规放射学监测对临床治疗的影响。
对 Embase、Scopus、PubMed、Cochrane 和 Ovid 数据库进行系统检索,以查找调查脊柱融合手术后术后影像学检查的研究。对影像学发现和因影像学而改变管理的比率进行了研究分析。
共检索到 9 项研究,这些研究按独特的患者或独特的就诊时间对数据进行了分类。报告每例患者数据的 4 项研究共纳入 475 例患者,其中 328 例(69%)接受了常规影像学检查。其中,28 例(8.5%)患者常规影像学检查结果异常,但无患者临床病程发生变化。在报告就诊数据的 5 项研究中,共纳入 3119 例就诊,其中 2365 例(76%)就诊时伴有影像学检查。在这 5 项研究中,146 例(6.2%)就诊发现异常影像学表现,仅有 12 例(0.5%)随后的治疗发生改变。
我们的分析发现,脊柱融合手术后的常规影像学检查对临床管理没有直接益处。基线影像学检查对长期比较和医疗法律问题的作用尚未研究,这仍取决于提供者的判断。需要进一步研究以确定脊柱融合术后的最佳影像学标准。