McGovern Center For Humanities & Ethics, University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, Houston, Texas, USA.
Department of Philosophy and Religion, American University, Washington, Washington DC, USA.
Account Res. 2024 Dec;31(2):158-172. doi: 10.1080/08989621.2022.2111257. Epub 2022 Aug 18.
How often a researcher is cited usually plays a decisive role in that person's career advancement, because academic institutions often use citation metrics, either explicitly or implicitly, to estimate research impact and productivity. Research has shown, however, that citation patterns and practices are affected by various biases, including the prestige of the authors being cited and their gender, race, and nationality, whether self-attested or perceived. Some commentators have proposed that researchers can address biases related to social identity or position by including a Citation Diversity Statement in a manuscript submitted for publication. A Citation Diversity Statement is a paragraph placed before the reference section of a manuscript in which the authors address the diversity and equitability of their references in terms of gender, race, ethnicity, or other factors and affirm a commitment to promoting equity and diversity in sources and references. The present commentary considers arguments in favor of Citation Diversity Statements, and some practical and ethical issues that these statements raise.
研究者的被引频次通常对其职业发展起着决定性的作用,因为学术机构经常(无论是明确地还是隐晦地)使用引文计量指标来评估研究的影响力和生产力。然而,研究表明,引文模式和做法受到各种偏见的影响,包括被引作者的声望及其性别、种族和国籍,无论是自我证明的还是感知到的。一些评论员提出,研究人员可以在提交发表的手稿中包含引文多样性声明,以解决与社会身份或地位相关的偏见。引文多样性声明是放在手稿参考文献部分之前的一个段落,作者在其中根据性别、种族、族裔或其他因素来论述其参考文献的多样性和公平性,并承诺在来源和参考文献中促进公平和多样性。本评论考虑了支持引文多样性声明的论点,以及这些声明引发的一些实际和伦理问题。