Wu Xiao, Bajaj Suryansh, Khunte Mihir, Revzin Margarita, Gandhi Dheeraj, Wintermark Max, Sanelli Pina, Forman Howard, Malhotra Ajay
From the Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, Yale School of Medicine, Box 208042, Tompkins East 2, 333 Cedar St, New Haven, CT 06520-8042 (X.W., S.B., M.K., M.R., H.F., A.M.); Department Radiology, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Md (D.G.); Department of Radiology, Stanford University, Stanford, Calif (M.W.); and Department of Radiology, Northwell Health, Manhasset, NY (P.S.).
Radiology. 2022 Dec;305(3):640-647. doi: 10.1148/radiol.220643. Epub 2022 Aug 9.
Background There have been growing efforts nationally and institutionally toward diversity in radiology. Purpose To analyze sex and racial and ethnic diversity over time (2010-2019) for the various levels of the U.S. academic radiology physician workforce in context of the available pipeline of medical students and trainees. Materials and Methods Data on sex and race and ethnicity were collected among medical school applicants, graduates, radiology residency applicants, residents, and different levels of academic radiology faculty. All trainee data were obtained from two time points, 2010-2011 and 2019-2020. Radiology faculty data were collected from 2010 to 2019. The sex and racial and ethnic composition at each academic level was compared between 2010 and 2019 using the χ test and a significance level of < .05. Results In 2019, the percentage of female faculty among radiology instructors was 38% (251 of 655); assistant professors, 31% (1503 of 4801); associate professors, 28% (600 of 2161); professors, 22% (424 of 1901); and department chairs, 17% (37 of 220). The proportion of female faculty increased from 2010 to 2019, with the greatest relative increase in percentages among the more senior faculty positions. However, the proportion of female department chairs has only increased from 13% (27 of 203) in 2010 to 17% (37 of 220) in 2019. Across training levels, the most abrupt change in composition of female trainees occurred from medical school matriculates (52%, 11 160 of 21 614) to radiology residency applicants (29%, 656 of 2274), which largely stayed unchanged from 2010 to 2019. The proportion of Black or African American department chairs was 5% (10 of 220) in 2019, which was higher compared with that of assistant professor, associate professor, and professor levels for Black or African American faculty (3% [130 of 4949], 2% [41 of 2208], and 2% [35 of 1924], respectively), with proportions of Hispanic faculty at 5% (240 of 4949), 4% (96 of 2208), and 3% (60 of 1924), respectively. These proportions have not changed since 2010. Conclusion Identifying and addressing reasons for the low proportion of female radiology residency applicants despite a highly diverse pool of medical students would be key to increasing female representation in the field. The low representation of African American and Hispanic individuals in academic radiology is seen at all levels and has not changed much over time. Efforts to increase diversity may need to be focused toward the medical school and residency application levels. © RSNA, 2022 See also the editorial by Pandharipande and Shah in this issue.
在全国范围内以及各机构中,为实现放射学领域的多元化,人们付出了越来越多的努力。目的:结合医学院学生和实习生的现有渠道,分析2010 - 2019年期间美国学术放射科医师队伍各层级的性别、种族和民族多样性。材料与方法:收集医学院申请者、毕业生、放射科住院医师申请者、住院医师以及不同层级学术放射科教员的性别、种族和民族数据。所有实习生数据来自两个时间点,即2010 - 2011年和2019 - 2020年。放射科教员数据收集时间为2010年至2019年。使用χ²检验比较2010年和2019年各学术层级的性别、种族和民族构成,显著性水平设定为<0.05。结果:2019年,放射学教员中女性教员的比例为38%(655人中的251人);助理教授为31%(4801人中的1503人);副教授为28%(2161人中的600人);教授为22%(1901人中的424人);系主任为17%(220人中的37人)。从2010年到2019年,女性教员的比例有所增加,在更高级别的教员职位中,相对增幅最大。然而,女性系主任的比例仅从2010年的13%(203人中的27人)增加到2019年的17%(220人中的37人)。在各个培训层级中,女性实习生构成变化最显著的是从医学院入学新生(52%,21614人中的11160人)到放射科住院医师申请者(29%,2274人中的656人),从2010年到2019年这一比例基本保持不变。2019年,黑人或非裔美国人担任系主任的比例为5%(220人中的10人),高于黑人或非裔美国教员在助理教授、副教授和教授层级中的比例(分别为3%[4949人中的130人]、2%[2208人中的41人]和2%[1924人中的35人]),西班牙裔教员在这些层级中的比例分别为5%(4949人中的240人)、4%(2208人中的96人)和3%(1924人中的60人)。自2010年以来,这些比例没有变化。结论:尽管医学院学生群体高度多样化,但找出并解决放射科住院医师女性申请者比例较低的原因,将是提高该领域女性代表比例的关键。非洲裔美国人和西班牙裔个体在学术放射学领域各层级的代表性较低,且长期以来变化不大。增加多样性的努力可能需要集中在医学院和住院医师申请层面。©RSNA,2022 另见本期Pandharipande和Shah的社论。