Marques-Sule Elena, Chiva-Bartoll Oscar, Carrasco Juan J, Hernández-Guillén David, Pérez-Alenda Sofía, Francisco-Garcés Xavier, Sentandreu-Mañó Trinidad, Blesa Jesús
Physiotherapy in Motion, Multispeciality Research Group (PTinMOTION), Department of Physiotherapy, University of Valencia, 46010 Valencia, Spain.
Department of Physiotherapy, University of Valencia, Gascó Oliag 5, 46010 Valencia, Spain.
J Clin Med. 2022 Jul 27;11(15):4360. doi: 10.3390/jcm11154360.
Service-learning (SL) seems to be useful for healthcare students. This study aimed at comparing an SL program versus a traditional approach (TA) on moral sensitivity, ethical competences, knowledge, teaching quality, SL participation and performance, and satisfaction in physiotherapy students.
Randomized clinical trial. A total of 32 physiotherapy students were allocated to an SL group (SLG, = 16), or to a TA group (TAG, = 16). Participants had to create an exercise program for patients with heart transplantation and acute coronary syndrome. The SLG performed the program with real patients, whilst the TAG performed a traditional collaborative approach. Moral sensitivity, ethical competences, knowledge and teaching quality were assessed pre- and post-intervention. SL participation and performance and satisfaction of the SLG were assessed post-intervention.
After the intervention, the SLG showed higher moral sensitivity, ethical competences, knowledge and reported better teaching quality than the TAG. The SL program was useful, addressed a real need, contributed to learning, helped to solve problems, facilitated better comprehension, increased motivation, and students would like to use SL in other subjects.
The SL program had a positive impact on students, encouraging the implementation of similar SL interventions. SL may be considered a teaching-learning methodology of choice in physiotherapy students.
服务学习(SL)似乎对医学生有益。本研究旨在比较服务学习项目与传统教学方法(TA)对物理治疗专业学生道德敏感性、伦理能力、知识、教学质量、服务学习参与度与表现以及满意度的影响。
随机临床试验。总共32名物理治疗专业学生被分配到服务学习组(SLG,n = 16)或传统教学组(TAG,n = 16)。参与者必须为心脏移植和急性冠状动脉综合征患者制定运动计划。服务学习组与真实患者一起实施该计划,而传统教学组采用传统的协作方法。在干预前后评估道德敏感性、伦理能力、知识和教学质量。干预后评估服务学习组的服务学习参与度、表现和满意度。
干预后,服务学习组在道德敏感性、伦理能力、知识方面表现更高,且报告的教学质量优于传统教学组。服务学习项目很有用,满足了实际需求,有助于学习,有助于解决问题,促进了更好的理解,提高了积极性,学生希望在其他科目中使用服务学习。
服务学习项目对学生有积极影响,鼓励实施类似的服务学习干预措施。服务学习可被视为物理治疗专业学生首选的教学方法。