Department of Sociology, University of Missouri, Columbia 65211.
Department of Animal Sciences, The Ohio State University, Columbus 43210.
J Dairy Sci. 2022 Oct;105(10):8328-8341. doi: 10.3168/jds.2021-21720. Epub 2022 Aug 12.
This study aimed to understand the veterinary-client relationship and perspectives in organic dairy production systems. Twenty-three organic dairy producers and 12 veterinarians were interviewed using semi-structured, one-on-one interviews. Consultation with local veterinarians was typically infrequent, as there was greater reliance on other producers and organic industry professionals for advice on dairy herd health management, perhaps due to a shared focus on organic farming principles. Organic producers generally consulted local veterinarians most frequently to develop vaccine protocols, address animal health emergencies, and gain reproductive services. Common reasons organic producers cited for not regularly consulting a local veterinarian included the cost of veterinary services and a perception that local veterinarians have limited experience with organic systems and products. Some producers also expressed the idea that infrequent veterinarian usage is indicative of a healthy herd. Meanwhile, local veterinarians reported that organic dairy producers often delayed consulting them about individual cases until animal health problems were severe. Local veterinarians also identified challenges in servicing organic herds, such as the lack of standardized regulations between different organic certifiers and limited safety and efficacy data for many herd health products used by organic producers. In addition, their formal training generally did not include organic herd health strategies. Organic dairy clients were typically a small fraction of the overall workload for local veterinarians, which precluded their ability to accumulate experience. In contrast, a handful of specialized veterinarians in the organic milk processing industry work more frequently with organic producers and have published most of the available resource materials on organic dairy herd health. Veterinary-client partnerships could be improved through more open communication and discussion of the challenges identified in this study and through participatory research and outreach engagement that includes local veterinarians, organic certifiers, organic industry veterinarians, and producers.
本研究旨在了解有机奶牛生产系统中的兽医-客户关系和观点。采用半结构式一对一访谈的方式对 23 名有机奶牛养殖户和 12 名兽医进行了访谈。由于对奶牛群健康管理的建议更多地依赖于其他养殖户和有机行业专业人士,因此与当地兽医的咨询通常不频繁,这可能是因为他们共同关注有机农业原则。有机养殖户通常最频繁地咨询当地兽医来制定疫苗方案,解决动物健康紧急情况,并获得生殖服务。有机养殖户不经常咨询当地兽医的常见原因包括兽医服务的成本以及认为当地兽医对有机系统和产品的经验有限。一些养殖户还表示,不经常使用兽医表明牛群健康。同时,当地兽医报告说,有机奶牛养殖户在个别病例出现健康问题时,往往会延迟向他们咨询,直到问题变得严重。当地兽医还确定了为有机牛群提供服务的挑战,例如不同有机认证机构之间缺乏标准化法规以及有机养殖户使用的许多牛群健康产品的安全性和有效性数据有限。此外,他们的正规培训通常不包括有机牛群健康策略。有机奶牛养殖户通常只占当地兽医总工作量的一小部分,这使得他们无法积累经验。相比之下,有机牛奶加工行业的少数专门兽医更频繁地与有机养殖户合作,并发表了大多数关于有机奶牛群健康的可用资源材料。通过更开放的沟通以及讨论本研究中确定的挑战,通过包括当地兽医、有机认证机构、有机行业兽医和养殖户在内的参与式研究和外展工作,可以改善兽医-客户伙伴关系。