Di Traglia Rosalind, Rankin Sally, French Jonathan M, Ecott Kathryn, Burnand Henry, Monsell Fergal
Trauma and Orthopaedics, Bristol Royal Hospital for Children, Bristol, GBR.
Trauma and Orthopaedics, Bristol Royal Infirmary, Bristol, GBR.
Cureus. 2022 Jul 13;14(7):e26810. doi: 10.7759/cureus.26810. eCollection 2022 Jul.
Virtual teaching has proven effective for medical students during the COVID-19 pandemic. This study is the first to describe an undergraduate orthopaedic teaching strategy in the format of virtual trauma meetings (VTM).
Clinical medical students from the Universities of Bristol and Cardiff were invited to attend five VTM between October and November 2020. These were delivered by consultants and speciality doctors via Zoom software. An 11-item feedback form was distributed after each session to assess the relevance of teaching material, student confidence in asking and answering questions, and if students would benefit from further sessions. Several open-ended questions were designed to evaluate aspects of the session that were most useful, which orthopaedic topics were of high priority and if they had any suggestions for improvement. Our initial aim was to assess student acceptance of the virtual format. Several months later pre-recorded material was uploaded onto YouTube and post hoc questionnaires were analysed.
A total of 50 students attended, with a median of 11±6 attending per session, producing a total of 26 feedback responses. Among the responders, there were 10 males and nine females and 63% of the students were in their third year. 100% of students felt comfortable asking questions and 96% felt comfortable answering questions. X-ray interpretation and management of fractures were the highest priority subjects. The majority of students considered the interaction between senior and junior doctors most valuable, and the most common improvement suggested was the inclusion of polls or OSCE-styled questions.
VTM could be a useful resource to enhance undergraduate trauma and orthopaedic (T&O) education by providing student-focused material in an open learning environment.
在新冠疫情期间,虚拟教学已被证明对医学生有效。本研究首次描述了以虚拟创伤会议(VTM)形式开展的本科骨科教学策略。
邀请来自布里斯托大学和卡迪夫大学的临床医学专业学生参加2020年10月至11月期间的五次虚拟创伤会议。这些会议由顾问医生和专科医生通过Zoom软件进行。每次会议后发放一份包含11个项目的反馈表,以评估教学材料的相关性、学生提问和回答问题的信心,以及学生是否会从进一步的会议中受益。设计了几个开放式问题,以评估会议中最有用的方面、哪些骨科主题最为重要,以及他们是否有任何改进建议。我们最初的目的是评估学生对虚拟形式的接受程度。几个月后,将预先录制的材料上传到YouTube,并对事后问卷进行分析。
共有50名学生参加,每次会议的中位数为11±6人,共产生26份反馈回复。在回复者中,有10名男性和9名女性,63%的学生处于三年级。100%的学生觉得提问很自在,96%的学生觉得回答问题很自在。X光片解读和骨折处理是最重要的主题。大多数学生认为 senior 和 junior 医生之间的互动最有价值,最常见的改进建议是加入投票或OSCE风格的问题。
虚拟创伤会议可以成为一种有用的资源,通过在开放的学习环境中提供以学生为中心的材料,加强本科创伤和骨科(T&O)教育。