Centre for Alcohol Policy Research, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia.
Department of Public Health Sciences, Stockholm University, Sweden.
Int J Drug Policy. 2022 Oct;108:103827. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2022.103827. Epub 2022 Aug 16.
Significant declines in drinking among young people have been recorded in many high-income countries over the past 20 years. This analysis explored the role of gender - which we interpret as socially constructed and relational - to provide insight into whether and how gender might be implicated in declining youth drinking.
Interview data from four independent qualitative studies from Australia, Denmark, Sweden and the UK (n=194; participants aged 15-19 years) were analysed by researchers in each country following agreement about analytical focus. Findings were collated by the lead author in a process of 'qualitative synthesis' which involved successive rounds of data synthesis and feedback from the broader research team.
Our analysis raised two notable points in relation to the role of gender in declining youth drinking. The first concerned the consistency and vehemence across three of the countries at which drinkers and states of intoxication were pejoratively described in gendered terms (e.g., bitchy, sleazy). The second related to the opportunities non- and light-drinking offered for expressing alternate and desirable configurations of femininities and masculinities.
We identified an intolerance towards regressive constructions of gender that emphasise weakness for women and strength for men and a valorisation of gendered expressions of maturity through controlled drinking. Though subtle differences in gendered drinking practices between and within countries were observed, our findings offer insight into how young people's enactions of gender are embedded in, and evolve alongside, these large declines in youth drinking.
在过去的 20 年中,许多高收入国家的年轻人饮酒量显著下降。本分析探讨了性别(我们将其解释为社会构建和关系)的作用,以深入了解性别是否以及如何可能与年轻人饮酒量下降有关。
对来自澳大利亚、丹麦、瑞典和英国的四项独立定性研究的访谈数据(n=194;参与者年龄在 15-19 岁之间)进行了分析,研究人员在每个国家都根据分析重点达成一致意见。主要作者在“定性综合”过程中整理了研究结果,该过程涉及数据的连续综合和来自更广泛研究团队的反馈。
我们的分析提出了与性别在年轻人饮酒量下降中的作用有关的两个显著观点。第一个观点涉及到三个国家的一致性和强烈性,即饮酒者和醉酒状态被以性别化的术语(例如,卑鄙、卑鄙)来描述。第二个观点与非饮酒和轻度饮酒为表达女性气质和男性气质的替代和理想配置提供的机会有关。
我们发现,人们对强调女性软弱和男性强壮的倒退性别观念以及通过控制饮酒来表达成熟的性别观念表示不容忍。尽管观察到了国家之间和内部性别饮酒行为的细微差异,但我们的研究结果深入了解了年轻人的性别表现是如何嵌入和伴随这些年轻人饮酒量的大幅下降而演变的。