Martín-Calvo Nerea, Gómez Beatriz, Díez Nieves, Llorente Marcos, Fernández Secundino, Ferreiro Abal Ane, Pueyo Francisco Javier
University of Navarra, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health, 31008 Pamplona, Spain; CIBER-obn, Institute Salud Carlos III, 28029 Madrid, Spain; IdiSNA, Institute of Health Research of Navarra, 31008 Pamplona, Spain.
University of Navarra, Faculty of Medicine, 31008 Pamplona, Spain.
Cir Esp (Engl Ed). 2022 Aug 17. doi: 10.1016/j.cireng.2022.07.033.
The acquisition of laparoscopic technique skills in an operating room is conditioned by the expertise of the tutor and the number of training interventions by the trainee. For students and surgeons to use a laparoscopic simulator to train their skills, it must be validated beforehand.
A laparoscopic simulator box was designed, along with 6 interchangeable training games. The simulator was validated by a group of 19 experts, physicians with an experience from at least 100 laparoscopic surgeries, and 20 students of 4th to 6th grades of medical school (non-experts). To evaluate its construct validity, time-to-completion and the number of successfully completed games were assessed. We used 11 and 9-item questionnaires to gather information on content and face validity respectively. In both questionnaires, answers were collected through Likert-type scales, scored from 1 to 5.
The group of experts required less time and successfully completed more games than the group of non-experts (p < 0.01). The group of non-experts gave a score ≥4 points on each of the questions regarding the content validity of the tool, however, the experts rated with a significant lower mean score the need for the simulator to learn the surgical technique (3.68 points; p < 0.01). Regarding the face validity, all items were graded with a score ≥4 points except for the question relating to the spatial realism (3.82 points).
The laparoscopy simulation box and the games were valid means for training surgeons and medical students to develop the skills required for the laparoscopic technique.
在手术室中掌握腹腔镜技术技能取决于带教老师的专业知识以及学员的训练干预次数。对于学生和外科医生而言,要使用腹腔镜模拟器来训练技能,必须事先对其进行验证。
设计了一个腹腔镜模拟器箱以及6个可互换的训练游戏。该模拟器由一组19名专家(有至少100例腹腔镜手术经验的医生)和20名医学院四至六年级的学生(非专家)进行验证。为评估其结构效度,对完成时间和成功完成的游戏数量进行了评估。我们分别使用11项和9项问卷来收集有关内容效度和表面效度的信息。在这两份问卷中,答案均通过李克特量表收集,评分从1到5。
与非专家组相比,专家组所需时间更少,成功完成的游戏更多(p <0.01)。非专家组在关于该工具内容效度的每个问题上的得分均≥4分,然而,专家们对使用模拟器学习手术技术的必要性给出的平均得分明显较低(3.68分;p <0.01)。关于表面效度,除了与空间真实感相关的问题(3.82分)外,所有项目的评分均≥4分。
腹腔镜模拟箱和游戏是训练外科医生和医学生培养腹腔镜技术所需技能的有效手段。