Bernard A, Riviere A, Cottenet J, Madeleine L, Quantin C, Pages P B
Département de chirurgie thoracique, CHU de Dijon, Bocage Central, 14, rue Gaffarel, 21079 Dijon, France.
Departement de biostatistiques et informatique médicale, CHU de Dijon, Bocage Central, 14, rue gaffarel, 21079 Dijon, France.
Rev Mal Respir. 2022 Oct;39(8):669-675. doi: 10.1016/j.rmr.2022.08.002. Epub 2022 Aug 18.
France is characterized by the dispersion of its technical surgical platforms, and it seemed interesting for us to obtain information on quality of care compared to other European countries, which often have different organizations and practices. The objective of the study was to compare the 30-day mortality of patients operated on for bronchial cancer in France with that of other European countries.
We conducted a literature review on practices in different European countries. The terms used for the selection were: lung cancer surgery, 30-day mortality in different hospitals in European countries.
We selected 9 articles corresponding to 9 European countries. The correlation coefficient between the number of lung resections per year and the population of the country was 0.967. The linear regression model between number of annual lung resections and population showed that except for Great Britain, most of the countries were close to the linear regression line. Germany and France had a mortality rate of 2.887% and 2.937% respectively, whereas the average is 2.13%. Following sensitivity analysis, the mortality rates for Germany and France remained higher than the average.
France is among the European countries with the highest postoperative mortality rates. These results should induce surgical teams to adopt quality-of-care measures focusing on outcome analysis.
法国的特点是其技术手术平台分散,对我们来说,获取与其他欧洲国家相比的医疗质量信息似乎很有意思,其他欧洲国家往往有不同的组织和做法。本研究的目的是比较法国接受支气管癌手术患者的30天死亡率与其他欧洲国家的情况。
我们对不同欧洲国家的做法进行了文献综述。用于筛选的术语是:肺癌手术、欧洲国家不同医院的30天死亡率。
我们选择了对应9个欧洲国家的9篇文章。每年肺切除数量与国家人口之间的相关系数为0.967。每年肺切除数量与人口之间的线性回归模型表明,除英国外,大多数国家接近线性回归线。德国和法国的死亡率分别为2.887%和2.937%,而平均死亡率为2.13%。经过敏感性分析,德国和法国的死亡率仍然高于平均水平。
法国是术后死亡率最高的欧洲国家之一。这些结果应促使手术团队采取注重结果分析的医疗质量措施。