Madison Guy, Sundell Knut
Department of Psychology, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Department of Social Work and Criminology, University of Gävle, Gävle, Sweden.
Scientometrics. 2022;127(10):6029-6046. doi: 10.1007/s11192-022-04495-3. Epub 2022 Aug 17.
Timely dissemination of knowledge is essential and fosters development of knowledge both within academe and the wider society, not least for knowledge that serves practises outside of academia. Here, we compare six disciplines which provide health-related knowledge that serve the health and social services. Most previous research compares the size and impact of the body of publications belonging to each discipline, which ignores the distribution of seniority, productivity, and impact amongst researchers. Instead, we consider the whole population of academics in Sweden employed or active within each discipline, including those who have nil publications. The disciplines form three clusters, where researchers in Public Health and Nursing and Caring science claim about 15 articles per author, Psychology about 10, and Education, Sociology and Social Work less than four. Their numbers of citations follow the same pattern, and are substantially correlated with the number of articles. Tenured or full professors had about 50% more publications and citations per publication than had associate professors. The distributions indicate clear modes at 0, 4, and 16 publications for each cluster, and provide the proportions of researchers within each discipline who have no such publications at all. We discuss the implications of these results for policy, practice, and knowledge quality in the social services and the welfare sector.
及时传播知识至关重要,它能促进学术界乃至更广泛社会的知识发展,尤其是对于服务于学术界之外实践的知识而言。在此,我们比较了六个提供与健康相关知识以服务于健康和社会服务的学科。以往大多数研究比较的是各学科出版物的数量和影响力,却忽略了研究人员之间资历、产出率和影响力的分布情况。相反,我们考虑的是瑞典在每个学科中受雇或活跃的全体学者,包括那些没有发表过任何文章的人。这些学科形成了三个集群,其中公共卫生、护理与关怀科学领域的研究人员人均发表约15篇文章,心理学领域约为10篇,教育、社会学和社会工作领域则少于4篇。它们的被引次数也呈现相同模式,且与文章数量显著相关。终身教授或正教授的出版物数量以及每篇出版物的被引次数比副教授多约50%。这些分布情况表明每个集群在0、4和16篇出版物处有明显的众数,并给出了每个学科中完全没有此类出版物的研究人员比例。我们讨论了这些结果对社会服务和福利部门的政策、实践及知识质量的影响。