Faculty of Health Medicine and Life Sciences, Department of Health Services Research, CAPHRI Care and Public Health Research Institute, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
The Living Lab in Ageing & Long-Term Care, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2022 Aug 25;17(8):e0268281. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0268281. eCollection 2022.
In nursing homes, narrative data are collected to evaluate quality of care as perceived by residents or their family members. This results in a large amount of textual data. However, as the volume of data increases, it becomes beyond the capability of humans to analyze it. This study aims to explore the usefulness of text mining approaches regarding narrative data gathered in a nursing home setting.
Exploratory study showing a variety of text mining approaches.
Data has been collected as part of the project 'Connecting Conversations': assessing experienced quality of care by conducting individual interviews with residents of nursing homes (n = 39), family members (n = 37) and care professionals (n = 49).
Several pre-processing steps were applied. A variety of text mining analyses were conducted: individual word frequencies, bigram frequencies, a correlation analysis and a sentiment analysis. A survey was conducted to establish a sentiment analysis model tailored to text collected in long-term care for older adults.
Residents, family members and care professionals uttered respectively 285, 362 and 549 words per interview. Word frequency analysis showed that words that occurred most frequently in the interviews are often positive. Despite some differences in word usage, correlation analysis displayed that similar words are used by all three groups to describe quality of care. Most interviews displayed a neutral sentiment. Care professionals expressed a more diverse sentiment compared to residents and family members. A topic clustering analysis showed a total of 12 topics including 'relations' and 'care environment'.
This study demonstrates the usefulness of text mining to extend our knowledge regarding quality of care in a nursing home setting. With the rise of textual (narrative) data, text mining can lead to valuable new insights for long-term care for older adults.
在养老院中,通过收集叙事数据来评估居民或其家庭成员感知到的护理质量。这会产生大量的文本数据。然而,随着数据量的增加,人类分析数据的能力已经捉襟见肘。本研究旨在探讨在养老院环境中收集的叙事数据的文本挖掘方法的有用性。
展示各种文本挖掘方法的探索性研究。
数据是作为项目“连接对话”的一部分收集的:通过对养老院居民(n=39)、家庭成员(n=37)和护理专业人员(n=49)进行个人访谈,评估他们所经历的护理质量。
应用了多种预处理步骤。进行了各种文本挖掘分析:单个单词频率、双词频率、相关分析和情感分析。进行了一项调查,以建立针对老年人长期护理中收集的文本的情感分析模型。
每位受访者分别说出 285、362 和 549 个单词。词频分析表明,访谈中最常出现的词往往是积极的。尽管在词汇使用上存在一些差异,但相关分析显示,所有三组都使用类似的词来描述护理质量。大多数访谈显示出中立的情绪。与居民和家庭成员相比,护理专业人员的情绪表达更为多样化。主题聚类分析显示,共有 12 个主题,包括“关系”和“护理环境”。
本研究证明了文本挖掘在扩展我们对养老院护理质量的理解方面的有用性。随着文本(叙事)数据的增加,文本挖掘可以为老年人的长期护理提供有价值的新见解。