Ciobotaru Vlad, Tadros Victor-Xavier, Batistella Marcos, Maupas Eric, Gallet Romain, Decante Benoit, Lebret Emmanuel, Gerardin Benoit, Hascoet Sebastien
Structural and Valvular Unit, Hôpital Privé les Franciscaines, 7 Rue Jean Bouin, 30000 Nîmes, France.
Hôpital Marie Lannelongue, Groupe Hospitalier Paris Saint Joseph, Faculté de Médecine Paris-Saclay, Université Paris-Saclay, Inserm UMR-S 999, BME Lab, 133 Avenue de la Résistance, 92350 Le Plessis Robinson, France.
J Clin Med. 2022 Aug 15;11(16):4758. doi: 10.3390/jcm11164758.
Percutaneous closure of paravalvular leak (PVL) has emerged as an alternative to surgical management in selected cases. Achieving complete PVL occlusion, while respecting prosthesis function remains challenging. A multimodal imaging analysis of PVL morphology before and during the procedure is mandatory to select an appropriate device. We aim to explore the additional value of 3D printing in predicting device related adverse events including mechanical valve leaflet blockade, risk of device embolization and residual shunting.
From the FFPP registries (NCT05089136 and NCT05117359), we included 11 transcatheter PVL closure procedures from three centers for which 3D printed models were produced. Cardiac CT was used for segmentation for 3D printed models (3D-heartmodeling, Caissargues, France). Technology used a laser to fuse very fine powders (TPU Thermoplastic polyurethane) into a final part-laser sintering technology (SLS) with an adapted elasticity. A simulation on 3D printed model was performed using a set of occluders.
PVLs were located around aortic prostheses in six cases, mitral prostheses in four cases and tricuspid ring in one case. The device chosen during the simulation on the 3D printed model matched the one implanted in eight cases. In the three other cases, a similar device type was chosen during the procedures but with a different size. A risk of prosthesis leaflet blockade was identified on 3D printed models in four cases. During the procedure, the occluder was removed before release in one case. In another case the device was successfully repositioned and released. In two patients, leaflet impingement was observed post-operatively and surgical device removal had to be performed.
In a case-series of complex transcatheter PVL closure procedures, hands-on simulation testing on 3D printed models proved its usefulness to plan and facilitate these challenging procedures.
经皮闭合瓣周漏(PVL)已成为特定病例中手术治疗的替代方法。在尊重人工瓣膜功能的同时实现PVL的完全闭塞仍然具有挑战性。术前和术中对PVL形态进行多模态成像分析对于选择合适的器械至关重要。我们旨在探讨3D打印在预测与器械相关的不良事件(包括机械瓣膜叶阻塞、器械栓塞风险和残余分流)方面的附加价值。
从FFPP注册研究(NCT05089136和NCT05117359)中,我们纳入了来自三个中心的11例经导管PVL闭合手术,这些手术均制作了3D打印模型。心脏CT用于3D打印模型的分割(3D心脏建模,法国凯萨尔格)。该技术使用激光将非常细的粉末(热塑性聚氨酯TPU)熔合成最终部件——具有适配弹性的激光烧结技术(SLS)。使用一组封堵器在3D打印模型上进行模拟。
6例PVL位于主动脉人工瓣膜周围,4例位于二尖瓣人工瓣膜周围,1例位于三尖瓣环周围。在3D打印模型上模拟时选择的器械与8例植入的器械匹配。在其他3例中,手术过程中选择了类似类型的器械,但尺寸不同。4例在3D打印模型上发现了人工瓣膜叶阻塞的风险。在手术过程中,1例封堵器在释放前被取出。在另1例中,器械成功重新定位并释放。2例患者术后观察到瓣叶撞击,不得不进行手术取出器械。
在一系列复杂的经导管PVL闭合手术中,在3D打印模型上进行实际模拟测试证明了其在规划和促进这些具有挑战性的手术方面的有用性。