Hwang Hyesung G, Markson Lori
Washington University in St. Louis.
University of Chicago.
J Cogn Dev. 2020;21(2):166-190. doi: 10.1080/15248372.2019.1706521. Epub 2020 Jan 12.
Starting in the preschool years, children show socially exclusive behaviors, such as intentionally leaving out another child from a ball game. Prior research investigating social exclusion understanding in preschoolers primarily used interview methods and it is clear that the verbal and cognitive skills necessary to identify and reason about social exclusion become more sophisticated with age. Yet it is unknown how children's ability to identify social exclusion relates to their own behavior, such as their social preference for socially inclusive or exclusive individuals. Further, whether such social preferences remain stable or change across development is an open question. Thus, the current study investigated whether the ability to identify social exclusion develops in tandem with social preference behavior by assessing 3- to 6-year-old children's ( = 256) identification of social exclusion and preferences between socially exclusive and inclusive agents. Five- to six-year-old children correctly identified social exclusion and preferred inclusive agents over exclusive agents across two experiments. Three- to four-year-old children could correctly identify social exclusion, but did not show evidence of a preference for inclusive agents over exclusive agents. Children were also able to detect implicit, nonverbalized social exclusion equally well as explicit, verbalized social exclusion across development. These findings suggest that young children's social preferences are not wholly dictated by their ability to identify socially exclusive agents. This divergent pattern of social preference from identification has implications for interpreting social preference behavior in young children.
从学前阶段开始,儿童就会表现出社会排斥行为,比如在球类游戏中故意不让另一个孩子参与。先前关于学前儿童对社会排斥理解的研究主要采用访谈方法,很明显,识别和推理社会排斥所需的语言和认知技能会随着年龄增长而变得更加复杂。然而,儿童识别社会排斥的能力与他们自己的行为,比如他们对具有社会包容性或排他性个体的社会偏好之间的关系尚不清楚。此外,这种社会偏好在整个发展过程中是保持稳定还是会发生变化,这还是一个悬而未决的问题。因此,本研究通过评估3至6岁儿童( = 256)对社会排斥的识别以及对具有社会排他性和包容性主体的偏好,来调查识别社会排斥的能力是否与社会偏好行为同步发展。在两项实验中,5至6岁的儿童能够正确识别社会排斥,并且比起排他性主体,他们更喜欢包容性主体。3至4岁的儿童能够正确识别社会排斥,但没有表现出比起排他性主体更喜欢包容性主体的迹象。在整个发展过程中,儿童同样能够很好地检测到隐性的、未用言语表达的社会排斥以及显性的、用言语表达的社会排斥。这些发现表明,幼儿的社会偏好并非完全由他们识别社会排他性主体的能力所决定。这种社会偏好与识别之间的不同模式对于解释幼儿的社会偏好行为具有启示意义。