Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
University College London, London, UK.
Br Dent J. 2022 Aug;233(4):343-350. doi: 10.1038/s41415-022-4903-5. Epub 2022 Aug 26.
Patients deserve to be treated in a safe and clean environment with consistent standards of care every time they receive treatment. It is essential that the risk of person-to-person transmission of infections be minimised, yet it is also essential that planetary harm (and therefore public harm) is minimised with respect to resource consumption, air pollution, environmental degradation etc.In 2013, the Department of Health introduced the Health Technical Memorandum (HTM) 01-05 providing dental practices with advice on patient safety when decontaminating reusable instruments in primary care. This paper provides a commentary on HTM 01-05 and similar decontamination guidance. We believe all decontamination documents needs to reflect the so-called 'triple bottom line' - the finance, social cost and impact on the planet.The authors provide an environmental commentary on a number of items mentioned in decontamination documents, including autoclaves (including the use of helix tests), disposable paper towels, undertaking hand hygiene, using a log book, plastic bag use, the use of personal protective equipment, remote decontamination units, single use instruments, single use wipes, disinfection chemicals (for example, sodium hypochlorite) thermal disinfection and wrapping of instruments.It is hoped, in the spirit of the ever-increasing numbers of papers published to highlight how healthcare (and dentistry) could become more sustainable, that these critiques will be taken in the spirit of providing a beginning of further discussion from an environmental perspective.
患者每次接受治疗时都应该在安全、清洁的环境中,接受始终如一的护理标准。必须将人际间感染传播的风险降到最低,但同时也必须将资源消耗、空气污染、环境恶化等方面对地球的危害(因此也是对公众的危害)降到最低。2013 年,卫生部发布了《健康技术备忘录(HTM)01-05》,为初级保健中可重复使用器械的消毒提供了关于患者安全的建议。本文对 HTM 01-05 及类似的消毒指南进行了评论。我们认为,所有的消毒文件都需要反映所谓的“三重底线”——财政、社会成本和对地球的影响。
作者对消毒文件中提到的一些项目进行了环境方面的评论,包括高压灭菌器(包括使用螺旋测试)、一次性纸巾、进行手部卫生、使用日志本、塑料袋使用、个人防护设备的使用、远程消毒设备、一次性器械、一次性擦拭巾、消毒化学品(例如次氯酸钠)热消毒和器械的包装。
希望本着越来越多的论文发表的精神,强调医疗保健(和牙科)如何变得更加可持续,这些批评能够从环境角度出发,提供进一步讨论的开端。