Department of Dentomaxillofacial Radiology, Faculty of Dentistry, Ankara Yıldırım Beyazıt University, Ankara, Turkey.
Electrical Electronics Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Gazi University, Ankara, Turkey.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2022 Dec 1;51(8):20220244. doi: 10.1259/dmfr.20220244. Epub 2022 Sep 12.
Automatically detecting dental conditions using Artificial intelligence (AI) and reporting it visually are now a need for treatment planning and dental health management. This work presents a comprehensive computer-aided detection system to detect dental restorations.
The state-of-art ten different deep-learning detection models were used including R-CNN, Faster R-CNN, SSD, YOLOv3, and RetinaNet as detectors. ResNet-50, ResNet-101, XCeption-101, VGG16, and DarkNet53 were integrated as backbone and feature extractor in addition to efficient approaches such Side-Aware Boundary Localization, cascaded structures and simple model frameworks like Libra and Dynamic.Total 684 objects in panoramic radiographs were used to detect available three classes, namely, dental restorations, denture and implant.Each model was evaluated by mean average precision (mAP), average recall (AR), and precision-recall curve using Common Objects in Context (COCO) detection evaluation metrics.
mAP varied between 0.755 and 0.973 for ten models explored while AR ranges between 0.605 and 0.771. Faster R-CNN RegnetX provided the best detection performance with mAP of 0.973 and AR of 0.771. Area under precision-recall curve was 0.952. Precision-recall curve indicated that errors were mainly dominated by localization confusions.
Results showed that the proposed AI-based computer-aided system had great potential with reliable, accurate performance detecting dental restorations, denture and implant in panoramic radiographs. As training models with more data and standardization in reporting, AI-based solutions will be implemented to dental clinics for daily use soon.
利用人工智能(AI)自动检测口腔状况并进行可视化报告,是治疗计划和口腔健康管理的迫切需求。本研究提出了一种全面的计算机辅助检测系统,用于检测口腔修复体。
使用了十种最先进的深度学习检测模型,包括 R-CNN、Faster R-CNN、SSD、YOLOv3 和 RetinaNet 作为检测模型。ResNet-50、ResNet-101、XCeption-101、VGG16 和 DarkNet53 作为骨干和特征提取器,此外还采用了高效的方法,如侧边界定位、级联结构和简单的模型框架,如 Libra 和 Dynamic。共使用全景 X 光片上的 684 个对象来检测三种可用类别,即牙修复体、义齿和种植体。使用通用对象上下文(COCO)检测评估指标,评估每个模型的平均精度(mAP)、平均召回率(AR)和精确召回率曲线。
探索的十种模型的 mAP 在 0.755 到 0.973 之间,AR 在 0.605 到 0.771 之间。Faster R-CNN RegnetX 提供了最佳的检测性能,mAP 为 0.973,AR 为 0.771。精确召回率曲线下面积为 0.952。精确召回率曲线表明,错误主要是由于定位混淆造成的。
结果表明,该基于 AI 的计算机辅助系统具有很大的潜力,可以在全景 X 光片中可靠、准确地检测牙修复体、义齿和种植体。随着更多数据和报告标准化的训练模型,基于 AI 的解决方案将很快应用于牙科诊所。