Çelik Berrin, Mikaeili Mahsa, Genç Mehmet Z, Çelik Mahmut E
Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology Department, Faculty of Dentistry, Ankara Yıldırım Beyazıt University, Ankara, 06010, Turkey.
Biomedical Calibration and Research Center (BIYOKAM), Gazi University Hospital, Gazi University, Ankara, 06560, Turkey.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2025 Sep 1;54(6):473-487. doi: 10.1093/dmfr/twaf029.
Deep learning-driven super resolution (SR) aims to enhance the quality and resolution of images, offering potential benefits in dental imaging. Although extensive research has focused on deep learning based dental classification tasks, the impact of applying SR techniques on classification remains underexplored. This study seeks to address this gap by evaluating and comparing the performance of deep learning classification models on dental images with and without SR enhancement.
An open-source dental image dataset was utilized to investigate the impact of SR on image classification performance. SR was applied by 2 models with a scaling ratio of 2 and 4, while classification was performed by 4 deep learning models. Performances were evaluated by well-accepted metrics like structural similarity index (SSIM), peak signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR), accuracy, recall, precision, and F1 score. The effect of SR on classification performance is interpreted through 2 different approaches.
Two SR models yielded average SSIM and PSNR values of 0.904 and 36.71 for increasing resolution with 2 scaling ratios. Average accuracy and F-1 score for the classification trained and tested with 2 SR-generated images were 0.859 and 0.873. In the first of the comparisons carried out with 2 different approaches, it was observed that the accuracy increased in at least half of the cases (8 out of 16) when different models and scaling ratios were considered, while in the second approach, SR showed a significantly higher performance for almost all cases (12 out of 16).
This study demonstrated that the classification with SR-generated images significantly improved outcomes.
For the first time, the classification performance of dental radiographs with improved resolution by SR has been investigated. Significant performance improvement was observed compared to the case without SR.
深度学习驱动的超分辨率(SR)旨在提高图像的质量和分辨率,在牙科成像中具有潜在的益处。尽管大量研究集中在基于深度学习的牙科分类任务上,但应用SR技术对分类的影响仍未得到充分探索。本研究旨在通过评估和比较深度学习分类模型在有无SR增强的牙科图像上的性能来填补这一空白。
利用一个开源牙科图像数据集来研究SR对图像分类性能的影响。由2个模型以2倍和4倍的缩放比例应用SR,同时由4个深度学习模型进行分类。通过结构相似性指数(SSIM)、峰值信噪比(PSNR)、准确率、召回率、精确率和F1分数等公认指标评估性能。通过2种不同方法解释SR对分类性能的影响。
两个SR模型在以2种缩放比例提高分辨率时,平均SSIM和PSNR值分别为0.904和36.71。用2个SR生成的图像进行训练和测试的分类的平均准确率和F-1分数分别为0.859和0.873。在用2种不同方法进行的比较中,第一种方法中,当考虑不同模型和缩放比例时,观察到至少一半的情况(16例中的8例)准确率有所提高,而在第二种方法中,SR在几乎所有情况(16例中的12例)下表现出显著更高的性能。
本研究表明,使用SR生成的图像进行分类可显著改善结果。
首次研究了通过SR提高分辨率的牙科X光片的分类性能。与没有SR的情况相比,观察到性能有显著提高。