Ha Sung-Ho, Youn Suk Min, Kim Ci Young, Jeong Chun-Gi, Choi Jin-Young
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Chung-Ang University Hospital, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Division of Oral Oncology, National Cancer Center, Ilsan, Republic of Korea.
J Craniofac Surg. 2023;34(1):96-102. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000008980. Epub 2022 Aug 30.
Orthognathic surgery is an effective surgical method to achieve functionality and facial esthetics for mandibular prognathism. If surgery is performed with a conventional method, errors may occur in the surgical preparation process and the surgical procedures, and there is a limitation in that the accuracy of surgery is determined according to the surgeon's experience and tactual sense. However, with the recent development of three-dimensional (3D) virtual planning and CAD/CAM technology, more 3D and predictable surgical planning and more accurate and time-saving surgery have become possible. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the surgical accuracy of 3D Virtual Surgery, CAD/CAM-Assisted Orthognathic surgery for Skeletal Class III Patients. The study included 18 patients who had undergone orthognathic surgery for skeletal class III malocclusion from January 2020 to December 2021. To evaluate the accuracy of the virtual planning, 3D facial cone-beam computed tomography taken immediately after surgery (T1) and virtual surgery data (Tv) were superimposed in each patient. Landmarks were set on each of the maxillary segment, mandibular distal segment, and left and right mandibular proximal segment, and the difference between T1 and Tv was compared 3D on the x , y , and z -axis. (ΔT: T1-Tv). As a result, the average distance between Tv and T1 at each landmark, all landmarks except for the posterior nasal spine of the maxillary segment showed <1 mm. In particular, the differences across the x and z -axis were very small, while the difference across the y -axis tend to be large. The comparison of the position of each segment in virtual surgery and actual surgery was as follows. It can be seen that all segments were located slightly downward, and the medial pole of the mandibular proximal segment was located posterolateral and the lateral pole was located anteromedial after the actual surgery compared with the virtual planning. It means that the proximal segment was slightly rotated, but the difference was within 1 mm, so it can be considered that the surgery was accurate. Base on this study, orthognathic surgery using 3D virtual surgery planning and CAD/CAM technologies was very accurate. By applying these cutting-edge technologies to clinical practice, it was possible not only to increase the predictability of surgery but also to improve the convenience of surgery. Therefore, it is thought that it will be important for clinicians to make continuous efforts to applicate cutting-edge technologies to be developed in the future to patient diagnosis and surgery.
正颌手术是一种实现下颌前突功能性和面部美观的有效手术方法。如果采用传统方法进行手术,手术准备过程和手术操作中可能会出现误差,并且手术的准确性取决于外科医生的经验和触感,存在一定局限性。然而,随着三维(3D)虚拟规划和CAD/CAM技术的最新发展,更具三维性和可预测性的手术规划以及更精确、更省时的手术成为可能。本研究的目的是评估3D虚拟手术、CAD/CAM辅助正颌手术对骨骼Ⅲ类患者的手术准确性。该研究纳入了2020年1月至2021年12月期间接受正颌手术治疗骨骼Ⅲ类错牙合畸形的18例患者。为了评估虚拟规划的准确性,将术后立即采集的3D面部锥形束计算机断层扫描(T1)与虚拟手术数据(Tv)在每位患者中进行叠加。在上颌节段、下颌远中节段以及左右下颌近中节段分别设置标志点,并在x、y和z轴上对T1和Tv之间的差异进行三维比较(ΔT:T1 - Tv)。结果显示,每个标志点处Tv与T1之间的平均距离,除上颌节段的后鼻棘外,所有标志点均显示<1毫米。特别是,x轴和z轴上的差异非常小,而y轴上的差异往往较大。虚拟手术与实际手术中各节段位置的比较如下。可以看出,所有节段均略向下移位,与虚拟规划相比,实际手术后下颌近中节段的内侧极位于后外侧,外侧极位于前内侧。这意味着近中节段略有旋转,但差异在1毫米以内,因此可以认为手术是准确的。基于本研究,使用3D虚拟手术规划和CAD/CAM技术的正颌手术非常准确。通过将这些前沿技术应用于临床实践,不仅可以提高手术的可预测性,还可以提高手术的便利性。因此,临床医生不断努力将未来开发的前沿技术应用于患者诊断和手术被认为是很重要的。