Department of Sociology, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, United States.
Department of Social Science, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, United States.
Front Public Health. 2022 Aug 16;10:966434. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.966434. eCollection 2022.
Education level is positively associated with adult health in the United States. However, new research shows that the association is stronger in some U.S. states than others, and that states with stronger associations also tend to have poorer overall levels of health. Understanding why educational disparities in health are larger in some states than others can advance knowledge of the major drivers of these disparities, between individuals and states. To that end, this study examined how key mechanisms (economic conditions, health behaviors, family, healthcare) help explain the education-health association in each state and whether they do so systematically.
Using data on over 1.7 million adults ages 25-64 in the 2011-2018 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, we estimated the association between education level and self-rated health in each state, net of age, sex, race/ethnicity, and calendar year. We then estimated the contribution of economic, behavioral, family, and healthcare mechanisms to the association in each state.
The strength of the education-health association differed markedly across states and was strongest in the Midwest and South. Collectively, the mechanisms accounted for most of the association in all states, from 55% of it in North Dakota to 73% in Oklahoma. Economic (employment, income) and behavioral (smoking, obesity) mechanisms were key, but their contribution to the association differed systematically across states. In states with stronger education-health associations, economic conditions were the dominant mechanism linking education to health, but in states with weaker associations, the contribution of economic mechanisms waned and that of behavioral mechanisms rose.
Meaningful reductions in educational disparities in health, and overall improvements in health, may come from prioritizing access to employment and livable income among adults without a 4-year college degree, particularly in Southern and Midwestern states.
在美国,教育水平与成年人健康呈正相关。然而,新的研究表明,这种关联在美国的一些州比其他州更强,而且关联更强的州的整体健康水平也往往更差。了解为什么在某些州,教育水平对健康的差距比其他州更大,可以增进对这些差距在个人和州之间主要驱动因素的认识。为此,本研究考察了关键机制(经济状况、健康行为、家庭、医疗保健)如何在每个州解释教育与健康之间的关联,以及它们是否系统地这样做。
利用 2011-2018 年行为风险因素监测系统中超过 170 万 25-64 岁成年人的数据,我们估计了每个州的教育水平与自评健康之间的关联,校正了年龄、性别、种族/族裔和日历年份的影响。然后,我们估计了每个州的经济、行为、家庭和医疗保健机制对关联的贡献。
教育与健康之间的关联在各州之间差异显著,在中西部和南部最强。总的来说,这些机制在所有州都解释了关联的大部分,从北达科他州的 55%到俄克拉荷马州的 73%。经济(就业、收入)和行为(吸烟、肥胖)机制是关键,但它们对关联的贡献在各州之间存在系统差异。在教育与健康关联较强的州,经济状况是将教育与健康联系起来的主要机制,但在关联较弱的州,经济机制的作用减弱,行为机制的作用增强。
要想在健康方面显著减少教育差距,全面改善健康,可能需要优先考虑为没有四年制大学学历的成年人提供就业和可负担收入的机会,尤其是在南部和中西部各州。