Karas Montez Jennifer, Hayward Mark D, Zajacova Anna
Syracuse University.
University of Texas at Austin.
Socius. 2019 Jan-Dec;5. doi: 10.1177/2378023119835345. Epub 2019 Mar 11.
Despite numerous studies on educational disparities in U.S. adult health, explanations for the disparities and their growth over time remain incomplete. We argue that this knowledge gap partly reflects an individualist paradigm in U.S. studies of educational disparities in health. These studies have largely focused on proximal explanations (e.g., individual behaviors) to the neglect of contextual explanations (e.g., economic policies). We draw on contextual theories of health disparities to illustrate how U.S. states, as institutional actors, shape the importance of education for health. Using two nationally-representative datasets and seven health measures for adults aged 45-89, we show that the size of the educational gradient in health varies markedly across states. The size varies because of variation in the health of lower-educated adults. We use state excise taxes on cigarettes to illustrate one way that states shape educational disparities in health. Our findings underscore the necessity of contextualizing these disparities.
尽管针对美国成年人健康方面的教育差异已有大量研究,但对于这些差异及其随时间的增长的解释仍不完整。我们认为,这一知识差距部分反映了美国健康领域教育差异研究中的个人主义范式。这些研究主要集中在近端解释(如个人行为),而忽视了情境解释(如经济政策)。我们借鉴健康差异的情境理论,来说明美国各州作为制度行为体如何塑造教育对健康的重要性。使用两个具有全国代表性的数据集以及针对45至89岁成年人的七种健康指标,我们表明健康方面教育梯度的大小在各州之间存在显著差异。这种差异的存在是因为低学历成年人的健康状况有所不同。我们利用各州的香烟消费税来说明各州塑造健康方面教育差异的一种方式。我们的研究结果强调了将这些差异置于具体情境中的必要性。