Hepatology and Liver Transplant Unit, IIS La Fe and CIBER-EHD, Universitary and Politecnic Hospital La Fe, Valencia, Spain.
Department of Medicine, University of Valencia, Valencia, Spain.
Transpl Int. 2022 Aug 16;35:10506. doi: 10.3389/ti.2022.10506. eCollection 2022.
Equality, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) are fundamental principles. Little is known about the pattern of practice and perceptions of EDI among liver transplant (LT) providers. International Liver Transplant Society (ILTS) EDI Committee survey around topics related to discrimination, mentorship, and gender. Answers were collected and analyzed anonymously. Worldwide female leadership was also queried via publicly available data. The survey was e-mailed to 1312 ILTS members, 199 responses (40.7% female) were collected from 38 countries (15.2% response rate). Almost half were surgeons (45.7%), 27.6% hepatologists and 26.6% anesthetists. Among 856 LT programs worldwide, 8.2% of leadership positions were held by females, and 22% of division chiefs were female across all specialties. Sixty-eight of respondents (34.7%) reported some form of discrimination during training or at their current position, presumably related to gender/sexual orientation (20.6%), race/country of origin (25.2%) and others (7.1%). Less than half (43.7%) received mentorship when discrimination occurred. An association between female responses and discrimination, differences in compensation, and job promotion was observed. This survey reveals alarmingly high rate of experience with racial and gender disparity, lack of mentorship, and very low rates of female leadership in the LT field and calls to action to equity and inclusion.
平等、多样性和包容性(EDI)是基本原则。关于肝移植(LT)提供者对 EDI 的实践模式和看法知之甚少。国际肝移植学会(ILTS)EDI 委员会围绕歧视、指导和性别等相关主题进行了调查。答案是匿名收集和分析的。还通过公开数据询问了全球女性领导地位。该调查通过电子邮件发送给了 1312 名 ILTS 成员,从 38 个国家收集了 199 份来自 40.7%女性的回复(响应率为 15.2%)。他们几乎一半是外科医生(45.7%),27.6%是肝病专家,26.6%是麻醉师。在全球 856 个 LT 项目中,女性领导职位占 8.2%,所有专业的部门负责人中女性占 22%。68 名受访者(34.7%)报告在培训或当前职位期间受到某种形式的歧视,这可能与性别/性取向(20.6%)、种族/原籍国(25.2%)和其他因素(7.1%)有关。当发生歧视时,只有不到一半(43.7%)的人得到了指导。观察到女性的反应与歧视、薪酬差异和工作晋升之间存在关联。这项调查揭示了肝移植领域令人震惊的高种族和性别差异、缺乏指导以及女性领导比例极低的情况,并呼吁采取行动实现公平和包容。