Centre for Health Systems and Policy Research, JC School of Public Health and Primary Care, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
The Jockey Club School of Public Health and Primary Care, Faculty of Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Room 418, 4/F, Hong Kong, China.
Eur J Pediatr. 2022 Nov;181(11):3839-3849. doi: 10.1007/s00431-022-04586-6. Epub 2022 Sep 2.
This study aimed to test the influence of vaccination characteristics and gain/loss-framing of information, on parental acceptance of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) vaccination for their minor children. A discrete choice experiment was conducted among parents of children aged 0-17 years from September to October 2021 in Hong Kong. Respondents were randomly assigned to four groups with different framing of information and asked to choose hypothetical vaccination alternatives, described by seven attributes that were derived from prior qualitative interviews. A mixed logit model was adopted to analyze the effect of attributes and information framing on parental vaccination acceptance. The vaccine acceptance rates under different scenarios were also estimated. A total of 298 valid responses were obtained. It was found that the BioNTech brand, higher efficacy, less serious adverse events and more vaccination coverage in children significantly improved parental acceptance. Additionally, loss-framing increased parental acceptance compared with gain-framing, while the presentation of mortality information did not make a difference. Acceptance was also associated with parental uptake of the COVID-19 vaccine and the children's age.
The findings imply that factors including gain/loss information framing, importance of vaccine characteristics, and peer influence have a significant effect on parents' decisions to get their children vaccinated. Parents with younger children had greater vaccine hesitancy, and information framing techniques should be considered in vaccination promotion for combating such vaccine hesitancy. Future studies could be conducted to identify the moderators and mediators of information framing to facilitate its implementation.
• Parental acceptance of COVID-19 vaccine was found to be associated with various socio-economic and psychosocial factors, while the evidence on impact of vaccination characteristics was limited. • Behavioral interventions, including information framing, have been used to promote various health behaviors.
• Loss-framing of information on vaccine effectiveness improves vaccine acceptance, while additional information on how the vaccine reduces death does not make a difference, which can be used to inform communication with the public in vaccination promotion. • The social norm (i.e., the vaccine uptake amongst other people) is important for increasing the parental vaccine acceptance rate.
本研究旨在测试疫苗特性和收益/损失框架对父母为其未成年子女接种 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)疫苗的接受程度的影响。2021 年 9 月至 10 月,在香港对 0-17 岁儿童的父母进行了离散选择实验。受访者被随机分配到四个信息框架不同的小组,并被要求选择由先前定性访谈得出的七个属性描述的假设性疫苗替代方案。采用混合 logit 模型分析属性和信息框架对父母疫苗接种接受程度的影响。还估计了不同情况下的疫苗接种接受率。共获得 298 份有效回复。结果发现,辉瑞-生物技术公司(BioNTech)品牌、更高的疗效、较少的严重不良事件和更多的儿童接种率显著提高了父母的接受程度。此外,与增益框架相比,损失框架增加了父母的接受度,而呈现死亡率信息没有区别。接受度还与父母自身对 COVID-19 疫苗的接种情况和儿童年龄有关。
研究结果表明,包括收益/损失信息框架、疫苗特性重要性和同伴影响在内的因素对父母为子女接种疫苗的决定有重大影响。年龄较小的儿童的父母疫苗犹豫程度更大,因此在疫苗推广中应考虑信息框架技术以克服这种疫苗犹豫。未来的研究可以进一步探讨信息框架的调节因素和中介因素,以促进其实施。
• 父母对 COVID-19 疫苗的接受程度与各种社会经济和心理社会因素有关,而疫苗特性影响的证据有限。• 行为干预措施,包括信息框架,已被用于促进各种健康行为。
• 疫苗有效性信息的损失框架提高了疫苗的接受程度,而关于疫苗如何降低死亡率的额外信息没有区别,这可以用于为疫苗推广中的公众沟通提供信息。• 社会规范(即其他人的疫苗接种率)对提高父母的疫苗接种接受率很重要。